I am pleased to announce the publication of my new book, A Catholic Engagement with Latter-Day Saints. Co-edited with my dear friend, Utah State University philosopher and Catholic convert, Richard Sherlock, the book is set for release by Ignatius Press on November 30, 2024. Among the other contributors are Rachel Lu, Alexander Pruss, Matthew Levering, and Brad S. Gregory. Here is the description of the book from the Ignatius website, followed by the Table of Contents:
A collection of Catholic scholars address several theological topics over which Mormons and Catholics hold contrary beliefs: the great apostasy, the papacy, the Eucharist, the Trinity, the incarnation, the nature of God, justification, sainthood, liturgy, and deification. The contributors, some of whom are converts to Catholicism from Mormonism, offer a respectful, though critical, analysis of LDS beliefs.
Catholics have done very little thinking about or interaction with the theological beliefs of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (the Mormons). The Catholic Church has focused virtually all of its ecumenical efforts on the ecclesial communities that arose from the Reformation, the Orthodox Churches, and Judaism. Left out of these discussions has been the Mormon Church, even though it has grown to nearly 16 million members internationally by 2016 from its modest beginnings in 1830.
This work examines the LDS faith as an important and serious challenge to the Catholic narrative of the origin and development of the Gospel of Jesus Christ. Absent the ad hominem attacks and lurid historical details that are often found in popular Christian assessments of the LDS Church, this book is intended by its editors to lead to further dialogue and better understanding.
Introduction: What Does Salt Lake City Have to Do with Rome?
Francis J. Beckwith and Richard Sherlock
Chapter 1: The Trinity
Matthew Levering
Chapter 2: Becoming like God: A Critique
Richard Sherlock
Chapter 3: Classical Theism, Latter-day Saint Theism, and a Long-Awaited, Though Modest, Rejoinder to the Roberts-Van Der Donckt Debate
Francis J. Beckwith
Chapter 4: James Barker’s Case for the Great Apostasy
James Hitchcock
Chapter 5: Deification in Two Traditions
Glenn Olsen
Chapter 6: Liturgy in Mormonism and Catholicism
Rachel Lu
Chapter 7: Catholicism, Mormonism, and Eucharistic Realism
Francis J. Beckwith and Alexander Pruss
Chapter 8: The Papacy: The Most Real Institution in the World
Ronald Thomas
Chapter 9: Latter-day Saint Pelagianism
Joel Barstad
Afterword: On Being a Catholic in Utah
Brad S. Gregory
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In