Public School or Private School?

This study surprised the researcher, will or will not surprise many of us, but the controlling for demographic features just might let loose an avalanche… anyway, here’s a clip:

Sarah Theule Lubienski didn’t set out to compare public schools and private schools. A professor at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, she was studying math instructional techniques when she discovered something surprising: Private schools—long assumed to be educationally superior—were underperforming public schools.

She called her husband, Christopher A. Lubienski, also a professor at the university. “I said, ‘This is a really weird thing,’ and I checked it and double checked it,” she remembers. The couple decided to take on a project that would ultimately disprove decades of assumptions about private and public education.

Studying the National Assessment of Educational Progress and the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study, they have found that, when controlling for demographic factors, public schools are doing a better job academically than private schools. It seems that private school students have higher scores because they come from more affluent backgrounds, not because the schools they attend are better educational institutions. They write about these conclusions—and explain how they came to them—in their book, The Public School Advantage: Why Public Schools Outperform Private Schools. Here’s an interview with the Lubienskis about their work, edited and condensed for clarity and length.

"Peter, I’m not asking for proof."

Religious People Like Science (RJS)
"Yes it is a hard thing to change entrenched behavior. I am glad to hear ..."

The Duty Of Constant Communion

The Jules Woodson Story: #churchtoo
"cmfe - You're quite the little keyboard warrior. I pity the wife you may or ..."

The Jules Woodson Story: #churchtoo

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Phil Miller

    It shouldn’t really be all that surprising. It’s the same reason why relatively few people fail out of Ivy League institutions. If your parents are paying a lot of money for the school, they want to make sure they’re getting their money’s worth.

  • SteveSherwood

    I do not find this surprising.

  • attytjj466

    That has long been recognized as a significant factor.

  • Mark Kennedy

    For long-time public school teachers, this is not a secret. Actually, pretty well known.

  • Lothar Lorraine

    In France many wealthy parents send their kids to private schools because violence in public ones has reached unprecedented levels.