Why Do Passionate Preachers Make Some Catholics Squirm?

I recently had a terrific Mass experience that has me mentally trying to answer something, so I thought I’d share my befuddlement here in the hopes that you might have some answers.

Case in point: me, sitting in Mass, listening to an amazing homily by a passionate preacher. He’s on fire, and actually has been since he processed down the center aisle at the beginning of Mass. He doesn’t just “say Mass”, he proclaims it with his entire person. His prayers aren’t said by rote. This priest varies the cadence of his proclamations each time I hear him say Mass, emphasizing different words at different times.

I’m good, until I notice the couple sitting near me, snarls on their faces. At first I think their snarls are prompted by the music, but then I realize that it’s just that they are completely uncomfortable with this particular style of passionate preaching. They’d prefer to come to Mass, stick to the cadence they’ve always known, and not to venture out of their comfort zone. I think there are likely others like them in the congregation, but since I intentionally sit towards the front of any Church to avoid my built-in tendency to muse during Mass, I don’t see the other nay-sayers.

But I know they’re out there.

So I bring this question to you, my fellow Catholic blog readers: Why Do Passionate Preachers Make Some Catholics Squirm? 


Like Patheos Catholic on Facebook!


Cry Room: Love or Hate?
Help Fr. Kevin McGoldrick: Catholic Priest/Musician Seeks to Record His Debut Album
"People Might Be Surprised to Know"... 2014 Profession Class Shares Their Stories
Did I Hear a Future Bishop Preach This Weekend?
About Lisa M. Hendey

Lisa Hendey is the founder and webmaster of CatholicMom.com and the author of The Grace of YesA Book of Saints for Catholic Moms and The Handbook for Catholic Moms. Lisa writes for several online and print publications, enjoys speaking around the country and is a frequent television and radio guest and host. Visit her at LisaHendey.com and connect with her at Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest or Instagram.