Questioning God (Guest post – Alan Molineaux)

During a recent theological debate with a friend, who had declared their Calvinist credentials, I was struck by a particular sentiment that all but ended our conversation. It seems that we human beings are not allowed to question God.

In raising issues about God’s character I was, apparently, in danger of being blasphemous. In doing so i was starting to resemble Job and we know that God responded to his predicament with the seemingly dismissive line ‘who is it who darkens my counsel’.

At first I wanted to defend my position by explaining that I wasn’t attacking God but merely questioning a particular view of him as represented by a their theological stance. But then I remembered the many ‘how’, ‘when’, and ‘why’ sentiments raised by the psalmists and wondered if it might, in fact, by acceptable to raise even the most serious of questions.

On the other hand if you consider humanity to be totally depraved then it probably stands to reason that the God of the universe doesn’t owe us anything.

I recently heard a prominent pastor inform his congregation that because we all deserve hell we have no rights and should be thankful that we have been allowed to live at all.

As I look at the frailty of my own humanity there is a temptation to think he might have a point until that is you consider the self revelation of God as Father. In this respect the creator God has offered a relationship to his creatures that allows for communication within the household.

If God had revealed himself to be a distant creator who had remained outside of creation itself then any attempt at raising a question or two would, indeed, be futile.

If, however, this God has indicated that he sees his creative role as that of a parent producing children it could be thought that he has a responsibility to that which he has birthed.

It’s difficult to imagine respecting any parent who would consider that they owe their offspring nothing. Quite the reverse in fact.

God, in his self revelation as Father, has declared himself to be responsible in his love for his children.

In this respect our exploration of this relationship should contain questions that allow for God’s revelation to flow through.

Following this thought I would want to answer that God does have a responsibility towards us and we are allowed to ask even the hardest of questions.

Even the Job passage can stand further reading when you consider that God did actually respond to the questions in a verbal way. It may not have satisfied the complainant’s intellectual faculties completely but God did not stand aloof from the events but became engaged.
God took the time to explain who he was to this frail human being.

There is hope for us all as we continue to ask life’s most difficult questions. We too might see our redeemer in the land of the living. We may start to understand something of the Father heart of God.


Thanks to my good web friend, Al Molineaux for this challenging guest piece.  Connect with him on Twitter.

"Well said. Whenever I feel annoyed every time I see that bumper sticker. My inner ..."

2 Reasons NOT to ‘Keep Christ ..."
"You also might find these seldom spoke of end-time prophecies interesting."

Why the Rapture isn’t Biblical… And ..."
"Can God's character change? That is the overriding question. If it can, none of us ..."

Greg Boyd Gives 5 Bullet Points ..."
"God helps those who lean on Him. :)(Isaiah 41:9, 10) You, whom I*(*Jehovah God*)* took ..."

Jesus Never Said: “God helps those ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Dan Martin

    If Jesus himself was able to ask “My God, why have you forsaken me?” I think the rest of us might get a little slack from our questions…

    Thanks for this post, Al!

  • Kheyburn

    Guess this person hasn’t read the Psalms – that are FULL of questioning, challenging, and debating with God. What a sad, empty theology it is that contains no room for such conversation with God.

  • Ianmichaelprout

    I’m glad you’ve brought this up. One thing I would add tho is that it is important to make the distinction between crying out to God “Why is this happening to me!?” and questioning that He is the ultimate authority. We can argue with men and that’s fine, but to say to God “I think I might know better than You” is idolatry in a sense I think. Of course I think the Calvinist you were talking with was probably asserting his definition of God as truth and insuing that you were blaspheming for disagreeing with his human understanding.