I asked for new voices and got some outstanding writers! Today we hear from the erudite James R. Harrington.
James R. Harrington earned his M.A. in Ancient History at California State University Fulleron and is a member of the Torrey Honors Institute. James has been a classical educator in a variety of settings over the past thirteen years. He lives in Houston with his wife, Sharon, and their daughter.
Mr. Harrington responded to thoughts on his first post.
Harrington wrote about the shield of Herakles,
He continued to the shield of Aeneas and followed up on that post. Now, unexpectedly, we turn to a shield in Ovid:
Virgil’s younger contemporary, Ovid, responded to Rome’s civil wars and the rise of Augustus with a poetic epic of his own. In his Metamorphoses, Ovid sets out to tell a mythic history of the world, from its creation down to the apotheosis of Julius Caesar. He draws a stark conclusion about the nature of reality that is more in keeping with Homer than Virgil: that the nature of Reality is flux and change. Writing as a well-educated Roman, Ovid is careful to give the legends surrounding the Trojan War ample space in his epic, and Achilles’ shield features prominently in Metamorphoses.
Ovid’s depiction of Achilles’ shield occurs at the beginning of Book XIII, during the contest between Ajax and Ulysses for the arms of Achilles after his death. It is a classically Homeric contest that pits eternal opposites against each other: Ajax’s brawn versus Ulysses’ brain. Ajax’s argument is as forthright as the man himself: he is the greatest fighter after Achilles, and Achilles’ cousin, so he deserves Achilles’ armor. Ulysses, true to his nature, tries a more complex gambit. He asserts that his stratagems have won more battles than Ajax’s strength, but includes a curious turn at the crux of his argument:
Think, when his sea-nymph mother had that high
Ambition for her son, was it for this—
That these celestial gifts, this work of art
So fine, should deck a rough and doltish soldier?
Why, he knows nothing of the scenes embossed
Upon the shield, the ocean and the lands,
The constellations in the height of heaven,
The Pleiads and the Hyads and the Bear,
Banned from the sea, Orion’s shining sword,
The cities set apart. He claims to win
Arms that his brain’s too stupid to take in!*
Ulysses’ erudition wins him the panoply, and a baffled Ajax commits suicide (much like his cousin’s withdrawal from battle after being similarly dishonored). Ovid’s story moves on to the fall of Troy, but the clever poet has left a tidbit here for the discerning. Ulysses will never enjoy the shield either. It will sink to the bottom of the sea in his wrecked ship.** Ulysses, for all his wit, does not understand the message of the shield and is therefore as unfit to carry it as Ajax. Achilles’ Shield, like Metamorphoses, depicts a world of constant strife and instability. Nothing ever stays the same, and so no thing can ever be kept by anyone. Both object and keeper are forever shifting into something else. Ovid, however, claims a different fate for himself:
… my name shall never die.
Wherever through the lands beneath her sway
The might of Rome extends, my words shall be
Upon the lips of men. If truth at all
Is stablished by poetic prophecy,
My fame shall live to all eternity.***
Stability, such as it is, can only be found in the realm of Art, where hammer blows and poets’ words give things a fixed form—a shield and a story.
*Ovid, Metamorphoses, A.D. Melville trans., New York: Oxford University Press, 1998. p. 303.
** I am indebted to Kathleen Vail and her work on reconstructing Achilles’ Shield for this important point. For her work, see https://theshieldofachilles.net/
***Ovid, p. 379.