America Meets Reverend Romney

In a post entitled “Three Course Corrections: An Open Letter to Mitt Romney,” I wrote back in January that Romney should not be afraid to “let his faith flag fly.”  I took some heat from some of my friends for criticizing the campaign openly, but my intention was to be constructive, so I forwarded the post to some friends in the Romney campaign.  While I’m certain that my post had no influence whatsoever, it represented a common sentiment in certain quarters that Romney was being over-programmed by his advisors and that he should not be afraid to let the American people see his Mormon convictions.

Romney was, in light of all the mockery and insults that are thrown in the direction of Mormonism, understandably reticent to bring his faith out into the light.  But evangelicals, I said, would actually be more comfortable with Governor Romney if they saw the real Romney a bit more.  For all our significant political differences, I knew that Romney prayed and sought God’s will and sought to live a life of obedience and service.  So I wrote:

“But they will grow more comfortable with you if they see the depth, the vitality, and the heartfelt authenticity of your relationship with God.  They will grow more comfortable if they better understand your pastoral experience (let’s call it what it is) as ward bishop and stake president.  You have rich experiences in missions and preaching and pastoral counseling, and in all these ways you connected with ordinary people, ordinary workers, in the struggles of everyday life.”

As I mentioned, I was not the only person making this case.  So I explicitly reject the delusion that I had any influence here, but I note this to mark the journey of the Romney campaign on the issue of his faith.  Witness Romney’s final answer from the Hofstra debate:

Let me transcribe the relevant part: “My passion probably flows from the fact that I believe in God. I believe we’re all children of the same God. I believe we have a responsibility to care for one another. I served as a missionary in my church. I served as a pastor in my congregation for about ten years. I sat across the table from people who were out of work, and worked with them to find new work or to help them through tough times.”  And this is not just talk.  There are countless stories of Romney counseling and serving and providing for the families who were under his care.  Countless stories of Romney going out of his way, and sometimes giving considerable resources of his own, to help families that were in need.

Not only did Romney own his faith and own the fact that his fundamental passions, convictions and motivations come from his faith — he owned his pastoral experience.  I’ve been pushing this point for nearly a year.  Even in the midst of a burgeoning business career, and even as he took a deep and active role with a very large family, he served in the local Mormon church as bishop of his ward and stake president.  Both of those roles required not only leadership but pastoring and pastoral counseling.

To provide some context: Mormons congregations do not have paid clergy.  Preaching duties rotate.  But the Bishop of a ward is essentially the head of pastoral care for all the Mormons in a certain area.  Stake President is another rung up the hierarchy.  Both of these require 20, 30, 40 hours or more of volunteer service on any given week.  Both of them, and especially the first role, put you in home after home, helping people through life struggles.

I know what that’s like.  My father is a pastor and served as a church elder (effectively, in the churches I’ve attended, the spiritual leaders of the congregations) for decades.  On many nights a week, he was out meeting with individuals and families from the church who were going through crises.  You cannot long stay “out of touch” when you’re talking daily to people who have lost their jobs, or whose children have gotten arrested with drugs, or whose spouses are hospitalized with cancer and cannot pay the bills, or whose marriages are on the rocks.  You cannot stay out of touch when you’re sitting across the table from people of all kinds facing every manner of human suffering and struggle.  Romney owned his experience as a missionary and as a pastor, and he should.  It’s the surest way to combat the “out-of-touch robber-baron” caricature.

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Mary

    Given the way he appears to be unable to talk to or connect with most people, I’m not sure that the fact he may have been in a counseling position means he was any good at it. Even when he’s trying to be nice he ends up being pretty insulting. President Obama seems to have far more skill in that area. And since his business was sucking the value out of companies, then leaving them bankrupt, I wouldn’t call ‘robber baron’ a caricature.

    • Timothy Dalrymple

      Do I need to explain for the hundredth time why your description of his business is itself a caricature? You kinda tip your hand when you describe a very successful capital company that helped an awful lot of companies grow in that way. Yes, there are cases where your money and consulting don’t help, and you extract the capital you can from a failing company in order to direct it to a succeeding one, but those cases were overwhelmed by the cases of companies that took their funding and their advice and grew substantially.

    • David Walser


      You, who was never counseled by Romney, consider yourself capable of judging his capacity as a pastor? This tells us far more about you than it does about anything else. We have the testimonies of numerous individuals who attest that Romney’s selfless service was of great benefit. They shed tears of gratitude as they recount his service. Why should we believe your baseless claims over their personal witness?