Is ‘Man of Steel’ a Red State Movie or a Blue State Movie?

My friend Jen Chaney and I don’t see eye to eye on everything. She’s tinged blueish. I’m a nice rosy red. So it was fun when we got together to talk about Man of Steel.

YouTube Preview Image

Read my review of Man of Steel.

Jen is a pop culture junkie who writes for the Washington Post, Esquire, and Vulture. You can follow her on Facebook or Twitter.

Despite its Title, Stephen Hawking’s Biopic Earns an “Incomplete”
“Princess Kaguya”: A Treasure for its Visual Beauty, Despite its Flawed Story
'The Overnighters:' Q&A with Director Jesse Moss
Video: Watch the Trailer for 'The Bible' Sequel 'AD'
About Rebecca Cusey

Rebecca is a movie critic. Check out her work on Rotten Tomatoes. Follow her on Twitter @Rebecca_Cusey

  • jcon526

    Interesting video. Appreciate the effort to bridge the gap across political lines, but … there is a lot of presumptions made here.

    On one hand, I agree that Man of Steel has obvious Christian ties, a strong moral discourse, a strong sympathy for the heartland, and spectacular action that seems reserved for a conservative crowd.

    However, while it’s fun to speculate about the political ramifications of a summer blockbuster, I believe categorizing Man of Steel across political lines needlessly presumes that “blue staters” can’t appreciate a hearty, mindless action flick or are too easily offended by the aforementioned values to enjoy the flick. It also, I imagine, insults the intelligence of “red staters” who may appreciate nuance in films (not that MoS was lacking it).

    Curiously enough, I agreed with your review: the film showed a noteworthy emotional range and breathtakingly entertaining action. I was dumbfounded at Jen Chaney’s utter dismissal of MoS (as I was with other negative reviews). I honestly cannot understand what was not to like about the movie.

  • Rebecca Cusey

    Yes. I was shocked myself. I was thinking “Did we see the same movie?” Funny thing is that Jen, who I totally respect and who knows WAY more about pop culture and movies than I do, felt the same way. She was astounded that I loved it.