Since we’re going to be talking about this topic a lot, I thought I’d throw up a post with some resources and thoughts.
First, let’s get our vocabulary clear. The weekly shabbat or sabbath of Judaism meant a “ceasing” of certain activities and encouragement of others. This weekly sabbath was Saturdays. In the New Testament, Sunday became celebrated as “The Lord’s Day” because that was the day whereon Jesus was resurrected. Earliest Christian practice was probably mixed, but it appears that these Christians refrained from work on Saturdays, keeping the Jewish sabbath. But, they met together on Sundays to partake of the Lord’s supper. This Christian one-two eventually morphed into our modern weekend. (More below.)
Based on a combination of inherited Protestant tradition, combined with passages like D&C 59:9-12, LDS generally transferred some of the Judaic ideas about Saturday sabbath-keeping onto Sundays, the Lord’s day. I say generally, because it’s not always the case that this falls on Sunday. In Israel, LDS treat Saturday like the American Sunday; that is the day LDS meetings are held on, by FP directive. (I quite enjoyed the “reverse weekend” as a student in Israel.) In Islamic countries, LDS meet together on Fridays, and treat that day like the American Sunday. In some countries like Hong Kong, services are held Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, etc. And of course, in 1980, the Church introduced the 3-hr Sunday block. Prior to this time, as the Encyclopedia of Mormon explains,
For many years, following the organization of the Sunday school in 1849, Sabbath services consisted of Sunday School in the morning and Sacrament meeting in the afternoon or early evening. Weekly ward priesthood meetings were held on Monday evenings, and fast and testimony meeting on the first Thursday of each month. In 1896, fast day was changed to the first Sunday to make attendance more convenient and less disruptive to members in their employment; in the 1930s, priesthood meeting was changed to Sunday mornings.
(See also “Sunday” in the Encyclopedia.)
So, Sunday might be a sabbath, but it is not necessarily the sabbath, in the sense of corresponding to the Biblical data, or in the sense that other days in other part of the world can be set apart as the day of worship among Mormons.
If you’d like to read more of the history of Sunday, I highly recommend BYU professor Craig Harline’s Sunday: A History of the First Day from Babylonia to the Super Bowl. (Craig’s done some other wonderful stuff, like his book on Luther, his autobiographical book on missionaries, and his BYU talk “What Happened to My Bell-Bottoms? How Things That Were Never Going to Change Have Sometimes Changed Anyway, and How Studying History Can Help Us Make Sense of It All” (which you can watch here.)
Now, if I had to teach multiple Sundays about Sabbath, sundays, etc. I’d probably take a historical approach: Sabbath in the Old Testament, Sabbath in the New Testament, etc.
The Old Testament categories don’t map perfectly onto modern life, particularly as they seem to be part of the Law of Moses, but the command to remember and keep the sabbath holy is part of the ten commandments. People can have different views, I think, on how “Jewish” (read: restrictive) Sunday should be, whether “much” (emphasizing the Law of Moses aspects as if the Jewish Sabbath transferred perfectly onto Sundays) or little (emphasizing that the Law of Moses has passed.) But regardless, ask yourself, do I decide what is and isn’t allowed in my life and my family based on some consistent principle that I can identify? Is it family tradition? Or is it just, we’re tired, and whatever keeps the kids quiet is fine?
Some New Testament thoughts:
We speak negatively of New Testament Jews having “built a hedge around the law,” but isn’t a lot of Mormon rhetoric similar? Don’t we talk about “avoiding even the appearance of evil?” (A misunderstanding of the KJV, btw, it means avoid every kind of evil, not things that might conceivably look bad but aren’t, in fact.) Don’t we tell the story about the landowner testing stagecoach drivers by asking who could drive closest to the edge of the cliff, then hired the one who stayed furthest away? Aren’t these the very same impulse found in the New Testament which we look down upon? As it turns out, some of those things we assume are non-Biblical inventions of Pharisaic judaism turn out to go back several hundred years. For example, when Jesus is criticized for having healed on the sabbath, and told the man to get up and carry his mat (KJV “bed”) and walk, he is criticized for carrying his mat on the sabbath. But look at Jeremiah 17:19-23 , where he reminds the Israelites not to carry burdens on the sabbath!
Thus said the LORD to me: Go and stand in the People’s Gate… and say to them: Hear the word of the LORD, O kings of Judah, and all Judah, and all the inhabitants of Jerusalem who enter by these gates! Thus said the LORD: Guard yourselves for your own sake against carrying burdens on the sabbath day, and bringing them through the gates of Jerusalem. Nor shall you carry out burdens from your houses on the sabbath day, or do any work, but you shall hallow the sabbath day, as I commanded your fathers.
For some further reading, I suggest
- this Jewish background online,
- The Sabbath by Abraham Joshua Heschel (a Jewish author)
- A collection of articles from good reference works on Sabbath and The Lord’s Day.
As always, you can help me pay my tuition here, or you can support my work through making your regular Amazon purchases through the Amazon links I post. You can also get updates by email whenever a post goes up (subscription box on the right). You can also follow Benjamin the Scribe on Facebook. If you friend me on Facebook, please drop me a note telling me you’re a reader. I tend not to accept friend requests from people I’m not acquainted with.