Who Wants to Talk about Downton Abbey?

Who Wants to Talk about Downton Abbey? February 18, 2013

I don’t usually do this, but the season 3 finale of Downton Abbey came out last night and everyone seems to be talking about it right now. It’s a fascinating show from a historical standpoint, but there’s also a lot there to analyze from a gender or class standpoint. There’s also a good deal to think about from a religious standpoint (especially Sybil’s take on religion and the conflict over whether Tom and Sybil’s daughter should be Anglican or Catholic). Since it’s one of my favorite shows, and since I’m sure many of you are big fans, I thought I’d open the floor to whatever discussion you all might like.


Interesting angles for thought/discussion:

First, what do you think of the writers’ treatment of Sybil? For myself, I think the character had a lot of potential, but that at some point the authors dropped all that. It’s almost like after she got married they forgot she was a character who could do anything other than, you know, getting pregnant. I can think of a million ways I would rewrite Sybil.

Second, what do you think the writers are trying to do with Edith? I’m honestly not sure on that point, because her sudden interest in women’s work and in independence seemed completely and totally out of character as established in earlier seasons.

Third, I’m really curious what the writers are going to do with both Tom and Mary. They are both widowed and each has an infant child to raise. I really have no idea where the writers are going to take either of them.

And also, like I said, analyzing the show from the standpoint of class, gender, and/or religion is really fascinating.

Anyway, what thoughts do you have?

"To available evidence, John Eastman has no shame and no decency."

This Is Racist Birtherism
"John Eastman lost that election after, among other things, he repeatedly tried to lie about ..."

This Is Racist Birtherism
"Legally she could, but it would be an uphill battle, 'cuz the law only applies ..."

This Is Racist Birtherism
"And aren't they the same people who so bitterly complain of illegals having "anchor babies?""

This Is Racist Birtherism

Browse Our Archives