Yvain has been reading Feser’s *The Last Superstition*, and he has an excellent gloss of one of Feser’s main points:

Feser’s argument is that most atheists arguing with Christians are pretty much the equivalent of a Calvinist going up to a Hindu saying “Look! John Calvin’s writings totally oppose abortion! Why can’t you see that?!”.

And then when the Hindu isn’t convinced, the Calvinist gets angry and says “Any reasonable person could see that John Calvin opposes abortion. Therefore, you must be unreasonable, and you must have decided to believe totally on faith that John Calvin supports abortion. That’s the only possible explanation for your stupidity.”

Atheists used to arguing with Modern Christians share most of their worldview with them. Atheists usually win these arguments, because the modern worldview logically implies atheism. The modern worldview is so pervasive that it is practically impossible for moderns to imagine anything else, and so if they meet a Traditional Christian, they will usually misinterpret everything they say and round off all of their arguments to the nearest Modern equivalent. These arguments almost but not quite make sense in a modern context, and so the atheist assumes the Traditional Christian has made a simple error and is just stupid.

This is pretty much the process I went through when I started arguing with smart, trad-y Christians in the Yale Political Union. My arguments were those of Dawkins and new atheists, and they didn’t match the claims and beliefs of my new interlocutors.

What’s *worse*, the Catholics and Orthodox I was talking to used some of the same words as the Modern Christians, but they meant radically different things. It’s basically like having an argument in French, except *this* dialect of French is composed almost entirely of false cognates, so it’s pretty easy to fail to notice that your opponent is speaking French instead of English.

Yvain is going to continue blogging through *The Last Superstition* intermittently. I think his distillation of Feser here (which mercifully lacks the insults to Dawkins and others you’ll find in the book — it’s *hard* to notice that your opposite number is speaking False Cognate French!) should make atheists a little curious about what exactly the Catholics are proposing. I basically shifted away from Modernity in Yvain’s diagram, and found that I’d ended up in Catholicism.

I’m noodling over the idea that atheism and Modern Christianity are much closer to having a common frame of reference than either is to Catholicism or Orthodoxy. Certainly, working off the same conceptual data set as many atheists, a lot of Christianities spiral down into Moral Therapeutic Deism or just really epistemologically modest pomo bible study groups. Given the assumptions of the modern view, atheism seems like a much more stronger attractor.

Part of Feser’s argument is that we gave up a lot of our philosophic vocabulary during the period where empiricism got *really *interesting *really *fast, and eclipsed some of the other questions we were interested in. It’s a big lift to get someone to study a new language, when you need the vocabulary they’re about to learn to explain *why* it’s so cool. (I hit this problem a lot recommending math/CS classes). *The Last Superstition* and Feser’s *Aquinas* are basically trying to make us deracinated moderns fluent again in their old native tongue.

Pingback: yellow october

Pingback: Herbs for Premature Ejaculation

Pingback: florida pet sitter

Pingback: enlevement epave gratuit 94

Pingback: Chef Murph K.T

Pingback: Naheed Ali

Pingback: Hules

Pingback: Best university in Kazakhstan

Pingback: English courses in Almaty

Pingback: sell online

Pingback: SEO indianapolis

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: Artist

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: build apps

Pingback: nvq level 3 customer service

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: All Natural Viagra Pills Save $$$

Pingback: Japanese Teen with Big Boobs

Pingback: johnny the healer complaints

Pingback: xxxcams.mobi

Pingback: internet directory

Pingback: poncelet or poncelet brian

Pingback: GoPro

Pingback: kangen water machine

Pingback: Celebrity Sexy Images

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: Alquiler de furgonetas

Pingback: cloud

Pingback: Pixel Film Studios

Pingback: aqui

Pingback: organize events

Pingback: hostgator promo

Pingback: host gator coupon

Pingback: hostgator discount

Pingback: hostgator coupon code

Pingback: hostgator coupons

Pingback: Hostgator Coupon Codes

Pingback: hostgator promo code

Pingback: Sending pet dogs & cats from Sri Lanka

Pingback: Pet Grooming Franchise

Pingback: power bank

Pingback: deffered action

Pingback: joseph chinnock scam

Pingback: cocaina in rete

Pingback: mafiosi online

Pingback: vendita droga

Pingback: viagra

Pingback: xxx

Pingback: Celebrity Swimsuits

Pingback: CMS

Pingback: forex no deposit bonus

Pingback: Celebrity Websites

Pingback: gruas burgos

Pingback: Celebrity Movies

Pingback: free money

Pingback: free porn movies $$$

Pingback: free natural viagra $$$

Pingback: free drugs online $$$

Pingback: weight loss

Pingback: free porn movies $$$

Pingback: Claims you are a winner

Pingback: code de la route

Pingback: AAAAA Plus Web design Birmingham

Pingback: Master's in Biomedical Sciences (MBS)

Pingback: portland oregon

Pingback: Promo Codes

Pingback: cleaner

Pingback: colombian brides

Pingback: aqui

Pingback: cialis online

Pingback: Actor Swimsuit

Pingback: executive recruitment

Pingback: Safest Private Planes

Pingback: MOT YORK

Pingback: MOT YORK

Pingback: MOT YORK

Pingback: MOT YORK

Pingback: HIPAA

Pingback: MOT YORK

Pingback: Business Jet Aircraft

Pingback: fucking

Pingback: we buy portland houses

Pingback: sell house fast Portland

Pingback: antalya masaj

Pingback: MOT YORK

Pingback: MOT YORK

Pingback: MOT YORK

Pingback: hooker

Pingback: Online Storage Auction

Pingback: Storage Auctions

Pingback: masaj izmir

Pingback: mattress singapore

Pingback: http://www.blueshop246.com

Pingback: mattress singapore

Pingback: Best Sleeve Surgeon in Lebanon

Pingback: mattress singapore

Pingback: Free fonts

Pingback: overhead door Orange

Pingback: storage auction

Pingback: Storage Auctions

Pingback: BDSwiss option builder

Pingback: recover panda hack method

Pingback: Porno

Pingback: ringen melano

Pingback: Flat Rock commercial insurance provider

Pingback: Trucking Dispatch Sotware

Pingback: auto insurance provider in Flat Rock

Pingback: Usenet kostenlos

Pingback: Frost & Remer

Pingback: Frost and Remer

Pingback: can you really make money taking surveys

Pingback: long beach

Pingback: tacos

Pingback: Frost & Remer

Pingback: m88

Pingback: What stock to buy now

Pingback: Nevada Casino

Pingback: pet sitter naples florida

Pingback: Bali yoga retreat

Pingback: daily dog walking naples fl

Pingback: Nevada Casino

Pingback: sex toys

Pingback: pet sitting naples fl

Pingback: логистика

Pingback: sex toys

Pingback: daily dog walking naples fl

Pingback: http://binaryoptionstradingx.com

Pingback: binary signals

Pingback: peixoto swimwear

Pingback: tempur pedic compare mattresses

Pingback: blood testing

Pingback: blood tests

Pingback: online fundraising

Pingback: personal trainer singapore

Pingback: la pornographie gratuite

Pingback: personal training

Pingback: Steroid Scammer Canada

Pingback: Fake Steroids Canada

Pingback: Teragon labs

Pingback: Sims Urban Oasis

Pingback: Fake Steroids Canada

Pingback: Apple product deals

Pingback: Western and Sunset Appliance Repair

Pingback: appliance service in Los Angeles

Pingback: prostituée

Pingback: stanton optical sacramento

Pingback: stanton optical roseville

Pingback: std testing

Pingback: Quantenheilung Köln

Pingback: furniture repair

Pingback: vinyl repair

Pingback: furniture repair

Pingback: stanton optical modesto

Pingback: xenical

Pingback: stanton optical stockton

Pingback: great mobile phones

Pingback: lisinopril

Pingback: v1agr4

Pingback: directory

Pingback: amazon coupon

Pingback: hack into Facebook

Pingback: escort mallorca

Pingback: izmir masöz

Pingback: izmir masöz

Pingback: website builders reviews

Pingback: masöz istanbul

Pingback: buy instagram followers cheap quick

Pingback: XXX

Pingback: Movies

Pingback: celeb gossip

Pingback: Epson & Sons Appliance Repair, Epson & Sons, Epson and Sons, Epson and Sons Appliance Repair, Epson & Sons Appliance Repair (562) 200-0545, (562) 200-0545, Epson and Sons (562) 200-0545, appliance repair in Long Beach, Long Beach appliance rep

Pingback: Epson & Sons Appliance Repair, Epson & Sons, Epson and Sons, Epson and Sons Appliance Repair, Epson & Sons Appliance Repair (562) 200-0545, (562) 200-0545, Epson and Sons (562) 200-0545, appliance repair in Long Beach, Long Beach appliance rep

Pingback: pain pills

Pingback: 411-pain

Pingback: buy youtube likes

Pingback: APARTMENT HELP

Pingback: PAY STUB GROUP

Pingback: Vietnamese Dong RV

Pingback: visit the website

Pingback: PROOF OF INCOME

Pingback: lose weight really fast

Pingback: Vietnam dong exchange

Pingback: Dong Revalue

Pingback: visit the website

Pingback: dryer repair

Pingback: Alhambra appliance repair service

Pingback: dog sitter naples fl

Pingback: appliance repair company serving Los Angeles

Pingback: click HERE

Pingback: 411 pain

Pingback: kassa opgelicht

Pingback: Usenet kostenlos

Pingback: appliance repair 91744

Pingback: appliance repair

Pingback: reliable pet sitter naples

Pingback: www.15min.lt

Pingback: james goetz lakeland

Pingback: vienna escort

Pingback: hair loss treatment

Pingback: wooden hot tubs

Pingback: volunteering

Pingback: videos porno

Pingback: Mcafee

Pingback: pic

Pingback: parachute soulac

Pingback: fmtrader نصب

Pingback: fmtrader نصب

Pingback: fmtrader احتيال

Pingback: fmtrader احتيال

Pingback: fmtrader نصب

Pingback: fmtrader نصب

Pingback: colon cleanse liver detox

Pingback: colon cleanse health

Pingback: pinganillo

Pingback: Kew Gardens NY orthodontist

Pingback: CMS EXPERT & DIGITAL STRATEGIST

Pingback: cisco

Pingback: Tagesdeals

Pingback: porno

Pingback: antalya masöz

Pingback: Anti-Aging Kosmetik

Pingback: symptoms of diabetes cure

Pingback: masquerade masks

Pingback: kroken

Pingback: build-a-bear workshop

Pingback: orijinal lida

Pingback: insurance

Pingback: build-a-bear workshop

Pingback: Celebrity

Pingback: fmtrader احتيال

Pingback: water ionizers

Pingback: koto anau

Pingback: 411 pain car accident

Pingback: sex

Pingback: solinea

Pingback: viagra

Pingback: free porn

Pingback: ammo

Pingback: canadian viagra

Pingback: turkiye botox

Pingback: Los Angeles legal recruiter

Pingback: angel medflight

Pingback: Hosting coupon Codes

Pingback: Felecia Mulhall

Pingback: ambulance worldwide

Pingback: porno

Pingback: flyambu

Pingback: air ambulance card

Pingback: Porno

Pingback: dreamhost coupon

Pingback: dreamhost coupons

Pingback: allo pizza

Pingback: dreamhost promo code

Pingback: cialis

Pingback: lida

Pingback: Viagra

Pingback: lifeinsurancequotesonline.co.uk

Pingback: other

Pingback: http://www.buyarticles.biz

Pingback: online porn

Pingback: Canyon Country News Paper

Pingback: click here for extra pleasure

Pingback: credencis

Pingback: hotel a Ferrara

Pingback: sail credit card processing

Pingback: Crime scene cleanup

Pingback: Crime scene cleaners

Pingback: business

Pingback: Fisher & Associates P.C.

Pingback: PartyFixx

Pingback: interior home design

Pingback: professional tweezers

Pingback: Illinois Process Servers

Pingback: Buy fire

Pingback: russian snip

Pingback: klinik aborsi

Pingback: karate Snellville

Pingback: kids safety and prevention

Pingback: Viagra

Pingback: standing pebble tile

Pingback: Viagra

Pingback: Bedbug

Pingback: lorenzo

Pingback: sophia hills

Pingback: novelty techpoint

Pingback: City of Santa Clarita Calendar

Pingback: foreign bride

Pingback: learn to sing yourself

Pingback: learn to sing better

Pingback: gadgets online

Pingback: Santa Clarita Sports

Pingback: Lawn Care Alert

Pingback: beauty products

Pingback: Nujabes

Pingback: Funny blogs

Pingback: best condo

Pingback: buy traffic

Pingback: muslim marriage events

Pingback: Crime scene clean up

Pingback: cat sitter

Pingback: chicago criminal lawyer

Pingback: pe.ofermedia.com

Pingback: buy moncler

Pingback: Way of the Web

Pingback: Cindy Marola

Pingback: Goedkope Vissen

Pingback: secure JVZoo

Pingback: mod farming simulator 2015

Pingback: monitor sql server

Pingback: cat sitter

Pingback: muslim marriage events

Pingback: Michael Horn

Pingback: url shortening

Pingback: Marketing online

Pingback: Pure Garcinia Cambogia

Pingback: Videos Gays

Pingback: government grants

Pingback: Sexo Gay

Pingback: Ground beef tacos

Pingback: masaj

Pingback: Want to buy Furniture in St. Louis? We deliver!

Pingback: masaj

Pingback: SEO Suffolk

Pingback: fuck teen girls

Pingback: Yelena Robertshaw

Pingback: ride on cars

Pingback: tre residences

Pingback: wedding dresses kleinfeld

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: whitening app

Pingback: nahradne diely

Pingback: iphone naprawa poznań

Pingback: Facebook

Pingback: Banc de Swiss steuern

Pingback: szybka iphone 4s

Pingback: interior design singapore

Pingback: interior design portal singapore

Pingback: allo pizza vesoul

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: Compositing

Pingback: Videos Porno

Pingback: Porno

Pingback: new year messages

Pingback: Find freelancer

Pingback: Bitcoin Widget

Pingback: Digital Dog Tag

Pingback: Clarkston, MI Small Company Loans

Pingback: porno

Pingback: porno

Pingback: merry christmas songs

Pingback: Small Business Lending Clarkston

Pingback: Visit Website

Pingback: here's some from me

Pingback: hair nutrient

Pingback: sears garage door repair

Pingback: toll fax

Pingback: howtohideyouripaddress.net

Pingback: villa interior design

Pingback: no deposit bonus

Pingback: Small Company Loans

Pingback: Fastest Small Business Lending

Pingback: buy prostitute online

Pingback: euro

Pingback: scandals

Pingback: penis enlargement pills

Pingback: park point Residences

Pingback: gadgets

Pingback: empresas peru

Pingback: how to make money online

Pingback: url shortener

Pingback: free porn

Pingback: free rape porn

Pingback: hyaluronic acid

Pingback: imprenta online

Pingback: Xenical

Pingback: water ionizers

Pingback: buy viagra

Pingback: sztachety PCV

Pingback: affiliate marketing

Pingback: ebooks

Pingback: Sztachety

Pingback: xxx

Pingback: dui defense attorney dauphin county

Pingback: coupocode

Pingback: porno

Pingback: treadmill pacemaster review

Pingback: nye party in boston

Pingback: Incestos

Pingback: four corners alliance group presentation

Pingback: peter beck

Pingback: tributo bruce springsteen

Pingback: Travod

Pingback: Listen Radio Online

Pingback: gost list

Pingback: quality red wine

Pingback: free article directory

Pingback: bebek gelişimi

Pingback: video games

Pingback: Videos XXX

Pingback: App

Pingback: make money online in malaysia

Pingback: interiors-net

Pingback: Small Company Loans Clarkston, Michigan

Pingback: Clarkston Small Company Loans

Pingback: Data Recovery

Pingback: Lic 911019 & 3rd Generation Roofer & 18 years experience

Pingback: kik friend

Pingback: kik usernames

Pingback: gravity boots

Pingback: The top ten VPNs for China