The Execution of Anthony Boyd : A Modern Lynching in Alabama
The scheduled execution of Anthony Boyd on October 23 is not simply the death of one man. It is a wound inflicted upon the moral soul of Alabama. To execute a black man in this state is to summon the ghosts of centuries past…to stir the air thick with the memory of terror, humiliation and ritualized violence. The blood of those lynched publicly…those left dangling from oaks while crowds cheered…is still puddled on the ground throughout Alabama. The names are innumerable. Imagine these persons as the horror was unfolding. Eyes wide with panic. Voices choked out with body fluid. Pain shooting throughout the nervous system. And still, the crowd calls it justice. Then again, if you can justify this then anything can be called justice. These were spectacles of terror…designed to assert control, to humiliate, to deny dignity and to enforce the social order of white supremacy.
Modern Lynching in Alabama as Historical Continuity
Anthony Boyd will die not by mob violence…but rather by the violent suffocation of nitrogen gas in secret. The mechanics differ…but the meaning does not. Both acts assert the same power over Black bodies…and strip the condemned of all agency and humanity. The rope crushed throats and hearts…the gas will steal enough breath to do the same. Like lynchings of the past…this execution asks Alabama to bear witness with cold acquiescence. Both communicate the same unflinching message…this one is no longer human…this life is expendable.
The Carnival of Dehumanization
Even as the state claims “justice”…there is a disturbing celebratory undercurrent in how Alabama interacts with executions. Headlines trumpet closure. Commentators applaud efficiency. The machinery of death becomes entertainment…a perverse measure of social order. Like the crowds who cheered lynchings of old…applauding the spectacle…present society sanitizes cruelty and calls it law. Justice is measured not by mercy or human dignity…but by conformity, closure and the satisfaction of seeing punishment executed…or “justice” served. This applause…literal or metaphorical…indicts every citizen who participates by watching, reading or even ignoring. From a theological perspective, this is blasphemy against the image of God in humanity…celebrating or ignoring cruelty is nothing short of idolatry…worshipping the false god of punitive justice over mercy and compassion.
Alabama’s Haunted Past
To understand this, one must see Alabama’s past as more than history…it is a living inheritance. In the streets of Alabama towns large and small, once lined with signs declaring “White Only,” the ghosts of lynchings linger. The courthouse steps where Black men were paraded and tried before being summarily killed echo in today’s death chambers. Jim Crow laws, segregated schools and buses and the terror that enforced “their place” for Black bodies were not isolated horrors…they were part of a continuous system of racialized power. The execution of Boyd is a continuation of that story. It enacts the same violent hierarchy…now veiled by procedure and technology…but still grounded in the same moral failure…the denial of the intrinsic worth of a human life.
Modern Lynching in Alabama & The Mechanics of Suffering
The mechanics may differ, but the physical and symbolic suffering overlap. Imagine the rope coiling, tightening around a man’s neck, his last gasps filling the humid air, echoing down streets where signs once read “White Only.” Now, imagine Boyd in a nitrogen chamber. Air thins. Breath fails. Silence falls. The terror is different…but the message identical…the state can decide whether a Black man lives or dies. Whether masked mob or bureaucrat, the executioner is the instrument of a system that has long sought to dehumanize Black bodies.
Moral and Theological Dimensions
There is a profound moral and theological dimension to this continuity. The absence of mercy echoes the absence of mercy in lynchings past. Every act of watching…every nod of consent…every look in the other direction…participates in the denial of the human dignity of Anthony Boyd. When a society sanctions the deliberate taking of life under the banner of legality…it reveals not the triumph of justice…but the fragility of conscience and the ease with which moral reasoning can be subverted. The ethical failure is collective…it is not merely in the hands of those on the execution team…but in the hands of every citizen who allows indifference, fear or habit to mask the gravity of what is done.
Modern Lynching in Alabama as a Performance of Power
Executing Boyd is not merely about ending one life…it is the reenactment of a narrative that has long defined Alabama…that Black lives are vulnerable, that the law can be wielded with cruelty and that justice is a performance rather than a principle. In both historical lynchings and modern executions, the Black body becomes a site for projecting societal fears, prejudices and assertions of dominance. The moral injury extends far beyond the condemned…it infects the community…distorting its understanding of justice and corrupting its collective conscience. It normalizes the idea that the innocent…or the marginalized…can be sacrificed in the name of order, ritual or procedural formalism.
What Every Alabamian Loses
Every Alabamian will lose something if Boyd is executed. Beyond the immediate tragedy to Boyd and his family, the state forfeits its moral authority, undermines the credibility of its institutions and signals that the lessons of history are not fully grasped. The ritual of execution, however methodical…carries a psychological and moral weight that echoes past atrocities. The ghosts of lynching victims…hover over the present…a reminder that societal violence is never eradicated but merely transformed. To participate in Boyd’s death is to deny the possibility of moral growth, to privilege cruelty over conscience and to fail the ethical imperative to interrupt cycles of violence.
Continuity, Not Progress
This is not progress…it is continuity. The rope has been replaced by gas, the mob by bureaucrats, the public spectacle by procedural formality…but the underlying moral calculus remains the same…a Black man’s life is expendable, and the community is asked to sanction that expendability. Every moment that passes without critique…every acquiescent glance from a citizen or official…is a complicit act in the erosion of collective morality. Violence dressed in legality is no less brutal…it is merely more insidious, allowing societies to believe they are just while committing acts that undermine the very foundations of justice…morality…itself.
Modern Lynching in Alabama = Alabama’s Moral Reckoning
Alabama faces a moral reckoning. To execute Boyd is to choose repetition over redemption, cruelty over mercy, symbolic violence over genuine justice. It asks citizens to sit with the uncomfortable truth that the specter of lynching is not a relic of the past but a force alive in the present, now cloaked in legality. Until that reckoning is embraced, the suffocation of Anthony Boyd will stand as a modern lynching…a testament to a state still struggling to reconcile its past with its conscience, a reminder that moral courage demands more than adherence to procedure or to what is legal. Humanity is not measured by the efficiency of its punishments…but by the fidelity of its compassion, the courage of its mercy and the seriousness with which it upholds the sanctity of all life. In failing these tests…the state offers not justice…but a hollow performance of it…a ritual that sacrifices the moral health of the community while perpetuating cycles of fear, pain and dehumanization. You can’t recoil in horror at the lynchings of the past…while being silent about the lynchings of the present.
*
*If you would like to support the Execution Intervention Project (the organization that financially supports Dr. Hood’s work), click here.
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In