Do You Have to Give Up Something for Lent?

Do You Have to Give Up Something for Lent? February 15, 2012

Part 2 of series:
How Lent Can Make A Difference in Your Relationship with God

I grew up hearing about Catholics who had to fast during the season of Lent. No meat on Fridays, only fish. This, you must understand, was a costly sacrifice in the cafeteria of Glenoaks Elementary School! The fact that my Catholic friends had to give up decent food in Lent always seemed to me to be one more good reason to be a Protestant. (Photo: I expect that the Lent Promo at the Luby’s in Kerrville, Texas was much better than my elementary school’s cafeteria rations. Unfortunately, the Lent Promo didn’t keep this Luby’s from closing.)

But, in the past fifteen years or so, I’ve sometimes decided to join my Catholic sisters and brothers in giving up something during Lent. This means, depending on how you count the days of Lent, fasting from something for about six weeks. (Officially in the Western world, Lent comprises the days from Ash Wednesday to Holy Saturday, the day before Easter. But many traditions do not count the Sundays during this period as belonging to Lent. Thus, Lent covers 46 days, but only 40 days belong to the Lenten fast.)

People in my theological tradition (the Reformed tradition, pioneered by John Calvin) tend not to emphasize Lenten fasting. Partly this had to do with the conscious rejection of Roman Catholic practices that were not clearly based on Scripture. Lent is neither taught nor prohibited in the Bible. One can be a faithful, biblical Christian and never recognize Lent. So, in days gone by, many Reformed folk and other Protestants who wanted to make the season before Easter special in some way, chose instead to add a spiritual discipline to their lives as a way of preparing for Easter. It’s quite common today for churches that don’t have midweek Bible studies, for example, to offer a Lenten Wednesday Evening Study or something like this. Special Lenten spiritual retreats are also increasingly common in Protestant circles.

But fasting still plays a prominent role in Lenten practices of many Christians across the denominational and theological spectrum. Throughout church history there have been different kinds of Lenten fasts. Nobody, to my knowledge, expected anyone to give up all food for the whole season. In the Middle Ages, it was common for Christians to give up certain sorts of food, like meat and/or dairy products. This explains why, in my youth, Catholics abstained from meat on the Fridays of Lent. Many Catholics still observe this discipline today. In the Eastern Orthodox Church, the Lenten fast is taken even more seriously than in the Roman Catholic church, with many Orthodox folk eating vegetarian meals during the season.

In recent years, I have often given up something in Lent, perhaps eating chocolate or watching television. The latter was particularly hard because I enjoy college basketball, and March Madness (the NCAA bastketball tournament) always falls in the middle of Lent. This year, I will give up something I enjoy. I’ve will also adopt an additional daily spiritual discipline. It don’t think it would be appropriate for me to speak in detail about what I’m doing at this time. But I would like to share some reflections on what I’ve been learning through my version of a Lenten fast.

What I’ve Learned by Fasting During Lent

First, giving up something allows me to make a tangible sacrifice to the Lord. Although certain sacrifices are already present in my life, they’re sort of “built in” at this point. I don’t often experience giving up something for God on a daily basis. The act of sacrifice reminds me of my commitment to God and my desire to make him first in my life. Let me add that my sacrifice in no way earns my salvation. This was completely earned by the once-for-all sacrifice of Jesus on the cross. My small sacrifice is a way of expressing my gratitude and devotion to my Savior.

Second, by giving up something I usually enjoy on a daily basis, I have sometimes found myself yearning for that thing. Frankly, I’ve been tempted to give up my Lenten fast at times. I could easily argue that it’s unnecessary (it is optional, after all) and certainly not required in Scripture. But, though I don’t think my effort at fasting makes God love or bless me more, I do think it raises my awareness of how much I depend on other things in life rather than the Lord. I see how easy it is for me to set up all sorts of little idols in my life. Fasting, in some way, helps me surrender my idols to God.

Third, when I give up something I like and then feel an unquenched desire for it, I’m reminded of my neediness as a person. And neediness, I believe, is at the heart of true spirituality. Jesus said:

“Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. . . .
Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, for they will be filled.”  Matthew 5:3, 6

Of course, feeling hungry for one of life’s pleasures isn’t quite the same as hungering and thirsting for righteousness. But, when I feel my hunger, when I sense my neediness for some other thing, I can use this to get in touch with my hunger and need for God.

Fourth, as I continue with my Lenten fast, I find myself less eager for the thing I’ve given up. Ironically, this makes my fast easier. It’s almost something I can take for granted, thus dulling the spiritual impact of the fast. But I’m also gratified to know that one of my little “idols” is being set aside in my heart, as I learn to depend more upon God. I’m experiencing a bit of freedom that makes me gladly thankful for God’s grace at work in me.

Adding a Lenten Discipline

Instead of or in addition to fasting during Lent, you might add a spiritual exercise or discipline to your life. If your church sponsors a Lenten Bible study, you might choose to join this study. Or you may want to participate in some act of kindness, such as feeding people at a homeless shelter.

I like to add something that I can do every day. It needs to be realistic, given my nature and patterns of life. So, for example, it would be a bad idea if I decided to get up at 5:00 a.m. to pray for an hour each day of Lent. This would stretch me so far that I’d surely fail. But I could take on additional Bible reading. Some years I’ve read one chapter of a gospel each day of Lent, taking it in slowly and meditating upon it. Other years I’ve used a Lenten devotional to focus my thought.

If you have no idea what to do during Lent, let me suggest the following. Set aside some time of quiet to ask the Lord what he wants you to do. See if the Spirit of God guides you to something. If nothing comes to mind, I’d recommend that you read a chapter of a gospel each day. If you start with Mark, you’ll have time to read all of Mark plus all of one other gospel during Lent.

Perhaps some of my readers would like to suggest Lenten disciplines that they have tried in the past, and how they have experienced God’s grace through these exercises.

So, as we enter the season of Lent, I am grateful for the saints who have gone before me, some of whom discovered the blessings of giving up something in Lent, while others grew in their faith by adding a Lenten discipline. No matter what you do during this Lenten season, I pray that God will draw you closer to him, and prepare you for a fresh experience of Good Friday and Easter. May God’s peace be with you!

"Great article on Thanksgiving. More of us should be thankful to those who work hard. ..."

A Simple “Thank You” That Makes ..."
"Thank You, I hope our paths will cross again. Till next time, make it a ..."

How to Make Your Job So ..."
""For it is not those who hear the law who are righteous in God's sight, ..."

Grace Will Find You Out
"Almost exactly sixteen years ago I attended a small gathering of pastors at a retreat ..."

Eugene Peterson When Nobody Was Looking

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Bill Goff

    is a good choice for Lent.  It is served
    in restaurants on the shore of the Sea of Galilee where it is called St. Peter’s
    fish – perhaps to make it more appealing to tourists.  In a restaurant run by kibbutz Ein Gev on the
    eastern shore of the Sea of Galilee, our tour group was served St. Peter’s fish
    for lunch.  My wife found a one shekel coin
    in the mouth of her fish reminiscent of Matthew 17:24-27.

  • Anonymous

    That’s cool. I did not know that about Tilapia. Any theories about how the coin got in your wife’s fish?

  • Bill Goff

    Our tour leader told us to be aware that there might be a coin in fish’s mouth.  I’m sure someone in the restaurant planted the coin.  As I recall my wife was the only one in the entire tour group of about 30 who found a coin in the mouth of a St. Peter’s fish.

  • Catherine Whittinghill

    I am not a member of a denomination that traditionally observes Lent, but last year I felt like observing the fast in some way.  I randomly started reading the book of Daniel, came across the passages about his fasting, and was extremely convicted to try Daniel’s fast – which involves eating nothing that comes from an animal (so totally vegan – no meat, eggs, or dairy), no leavened breads, and drinking only water.  This was really extreme (I had a totally normal diet beforehand), but I felt like trying it out.  

    I had no idea when I started that “The Daniel Fast” is a fast people frequently observe and have written lots of books about, and that this is the fast observed by the Orthodox Church.  Total coincidence, but a Greek Orthodox friend gave me a devotional from his church that I followed and loved.  

    This period of fasting was one of the most joyful experiences of my whole life.  I had a few “prayer goals” at the outset, but very shortly after beginning it became clear that this exercise would clear my mind of my own thoughts and heighten my sensitivity to the things the Lord would have me learn.  I paid closer attention to my own behavior, to the needs of those around me, and my prayers were lucid and meditative to an unprecedented degree.  I felt new courage to act on these promptings from the Lord and learned much about the depth of God’s love for me.  My sacrifices didn’t do anything “for him,” but instead focused my attention closely on the grace, joy, and peace he is always willing to bestow. 

    I recorded some moments here:  

    I’m starting the same fast again next Wednesday and can’t wait to see how the Lord will work in my life in new ways this year.  I enter the Lenten season with prayers for all those who wish to observe it.  

  • Anonymous

    That’s a fun story!

  • Anonymous

    Excellent. Thanks for sharing your story and the link.

  • Aimee Sanchez

    Thank you for sharing I also attend a church that doesn’t practice Lent but I am working in a church that does and I was thinking of participating  as well. I appreciate your suggestions and the challenge.