Op-ed: Popes and Presidents

Op-ed: Popes and Presidents November 1, 2021

THE Washington Post ruminates over how things have changed between John F. Kennedy’s visit to the pope in 1963 and Joe Biden’s this past week.

Image via YouTube


At the Vatican in July 1963, President John F. Kennedy and Pope Paul VI rose from their chairs and shook hands as cameras flashed and a videographer filmed. Traditionally, Catholics like Kennedy were expected to greet the pope by kneeling, taking his right hand and kissing the papal ring, a symbol of the office. Decades later, questions remain about whether the president’s decision to shake the pontiff’s hand was meant as a statement that his faith and his service to the United States could coexist without, as critics ominously predicted, undue subservience to the Vatican.

What a revolting display that would have been, had it happened. And while we’re on the subject, what is due subservience to the Vatican?

Surely Kennedy in his role as president shouldn’t have been subservient to the Vatican at all. Kennedy’s job was the wholly secular one of head of government, and any subservience to the pope while he held that job would have been an outrage. Who asked the pope to tell us what to do, or tell us what laws we can and can’t have? Kennedy should have stayed away from the Vatican, and so should Biden.

The Post goes on:

The meeting Friday between President Biden, the second Catholic to hold the nation’s highest office, and Pope Francis comes at a similarly contentious time – but in a nearly opposite way. While non-Catholics in the 20th century questioned whether Kennedy could avoid Vatican influence, the contemporary controversy centers on whether Biden’s break with his church on abortion rights undermines what he characterizes as his deep faith.

Image viaYouTube

Yes but that doesn’t matter. Whether Kennedy could, and Biden can, avoid Vatican influence matters a great deal, because the influence would be bad and because it would be religious influence on a secular government. Biden and his deep faith are an entirely different subject and of no importance or relevance to citizens of the secular country that elected him president.

Fox News of course has a different take on the subject.

President Joe Biden received Communion at St. Patrick’s Church during Saturday Vigil Mass, a day after saying Pope Francis told him he should continue to partake in the sacrament, prompting negative reactions from Catholic priests upset that the president’s position on abortion is not in line with Church doctrine.

But Catholic priests are just Catholic priests. They’re not the boss of us. They’re employees of a large international religious network, and that’s all they are; they have no authority over those of us who aren’t part of that network. It doesn’t matter that the priests had “negative reactions.”

They can go cry in their beer, but they can’t tell us or Biden what to do. It’s none of their business. It’s absurd to report on their ruffled feathers because Biden doesn’t always jump when they say jump. Biden doesn’t work for them, he works for the citizens as a whole, so he doesn’t take orders from them. It’s pretty simple.

Image via YouTube

“I fear that the Church has lost its prophetic voice,” Bishop of Providence Thomas Tobin, above, tweeted Friday.

Where are the John the Baptists who will confront the Herods of our day?

I don’t know, where are the John the Baptists who will confront all the Herods in all those churches who raped children for years and years and years before reporters at the Boston Globe finally blew the whistle on them?

Earlier in the week, Tobin had publicly challenged Pope Francis to deny communion to the president.

“Dear Pope Francis, You have boldly stated that abortion is ‘murder,’” Tobin said.  “Please challenge President Biden on this critical issue. His persistent support of abortion is an embarrassment for the Church and a scandal to the world. Thank you. Very respectfully, Your brother +Thomas.”

But the church is the church. It doesn’t get to tell us what to do. It doesn’t get to tell Biden what to do – not officially, as part of an official visit (which Biden shouldn’t be paying anyway). If priests want to chastise Biden in the church, they can go ahead, but they should stay well away from government business.

Why did Kennedy and Biden visit the pope anyway? Why did Trump? Why did Obama welcome the pope to the White House?

It’s Mussolini’s fault.

The accession of Mussolini, known in his youth as mangiaprete – priest-eater – didn’t bode well for the papacy. The fascist squads had been beating up clerics and terrorising Catholic youth clubs. But Mussolini saw that he could use the church to legitimise his power, so he set about wooing the clergy. He had his wife and children baptised. He gave money for the restoration of churches. After two generations of secularism, there were once again to be crucifixes in Italy’s courts and classrooms. Warily, slowly, the Pope became persuaded that with Mussolini’s help Italy might become, once more, a “confessional state”.

They had so much in common. It’s all about The One Supreme Manly Ruler, who gets to tell everyone what to do with no questions asked. They could be rivals, or they could agree to split up the privileges and help each other out. Mussolini and Pius XI went the latter route, and the Lateran Treaty was signed.

The Lateran Treaty is the agreement which was signed in the Lateran Palace in Rome, on the 11th of February 1929 by Italy and the Holy See which recognized the Vatican City as a sovereign and independent papal state. The Lateran Treaty is also referred to as the Lateran Pact of 1929. The Lateran Treaty was signed by Benito Mussolini as the Italian government representative and cardinal secretary of state Pietro Gasparri as the representative of the Holy See; and it was confirmed by the Italian constitution of 1948.

In other words the Vatican is a country, so presidents and prime ministers who toddle off there to say howdy to the pope have the fig leaf that they’re visiting a colleague. It’s all a farce, and we seem to be stuck with it.

"Costelloe claims that the 'church can and must also take whatever steps are necessary to ..."

‘Church has changed’ says archbishop after ..."
"I expect the 'holy father' had in mind members of the Roman church, such as ..."

Pope Francis: Better to live as ..."
"It hardly matters how you slice and dice it, the fact remains that the man-god ..."

Superhero Jesus comic branded ‘blasphemous’ by ..."

Browse Our Archives