Progressive Christianity has a lot of things in its favor: thoughtful theology, rich tradition, social engagement, etc. But too often it’s missing one important factor: passion. Some people probably gravitate to more conservative churches because, frankly, they’re bored and uninspired by worship at progressive churches. But it’s possible to be progressive and passionate.

One important aspect of being a more rousing church is music. There’s something about music that goes deeper than words alone. Music naturally facilitates passion, energy, and depth. Not only does music provide energy, but it also helps us learn and explore theology. It’s impossible to overestimate the importance of music. But progressive Christian music is rare. And progressive Christian music done well is even more uncommon.

I can testify to the need for such music. After serving a progressive congregation for a few months, I realized that many people didn’t seem very inspired by the hymns. They just weren’t connecting. No wonder. The lyrics had traditional theology, old-school metaphors, outdated wording, etc. Plus the music itself wasn’t the kind of music that people actually listen to in their car or on their iPod. The same hymns that may have made people misty with emotion in the 1950s or 1850s just weren’t having the same effect today. [Read more...]