I have just read an admirably concise essay that is one of the smartest and most interesting contributions to American religious history that I have read in a long time. In April, Jon Butler gave his Presidential Address to the Organization of American Historians, which has now been published as “God, Gotham, and Modernity,” in the Journal of American History (June 2016) 103 (1): 19-33: subscription is required. To oversimplify the argument, Butler complains that scholars (past and present) tend... Read more











