menu

Why It’s Impossible to Be a Catholic

Why It’s Impossible to Be a Catholic March 27, 2015

mosesIt’s those ten commandments. They’re impossible!

Not long ago I had an email correspondence with a man who was divorced and remarried.

He asked why the church could not be more “forgiving”.

By this I think he meant that he wanted the church to say his second marriage was okay, or maybe he wanted me to say the marriage was okay, that it by living with another woman other than his validly married wife he was not, after all, “living in sin”.

I wrote back saying that I couldn’t do that because I don’t have the authority to do it. What am I to do, take it upon myself to change the laws of the church–indeed the laws of God? Shall I tell a lie to make him feel good? Shall I soothe him into hell?

Is it hard to live with the Catholic rules on marriage? No. It’s not hard. It’s impossible.

Who, after all, can really keep all the rules and regulations of the church? The same people who have never broken one of the ten commandments.

This is where we have to stop and ask ourselves what the rules of our religion are for anyway.

Stop for a moment. The rules are not there because God thinks we can keep them.

The ten commandments are not set up as some sort of a practical guide book for life. They’re not given because they are utilitarian principles for living together and being nice people.

They might help us to do that, but that’s not what they’re for. 

The ten commandments and the laws of the church are set out because they’re true. That’s it. They are true and nothing more.

Each one of the commandments are deeply true–true down to the depths of reality. They are woven into the fabric of the universe and written in the cords of our hearts.

That’s why God said they should be written in stone–to make the point that they are immutable. They are the law not because it is something we can keep and fulfill, but because they are true and they cannot be changed.

Let us take an example: “You shall not bear false witness.” In other words, “Do not lie.” In other words, “Tell the truth”. Continue Reading


Browse Our Archives