Paganism and Catholicism

Over at Shrine of the Holy Whapping Drew was asking if anyone knew the origin of the bishop’s mitre. It reminded me that purveyors of the more wacky anti-Catholic propaganda believe the bishop’s mitre is derived from the ancient pagan religion of Dagon the fish god. (picture to the left) See how the priest’s headgear looks remarkably like a mitre? The tabs that hang down the back of the bishop’s mitre (they’re called lappets) are obviously the vestigial remains of what was a full blown fishy-type cloak.

There’s a fair bit of this material on the web, and I have to confess, I have a weakness for the stuff. I’m a sucker for bogus scholarship, way out conspiracy theories, arcane connections and obscure explanations. Yetis, alien kidnappings, miracles…’who really killed Princess Diana??’ you name it, I’m a fan.

I don’t really swallow too much of it. Instead, I’m fascinated by the sort of mentality that takes it all seriously. I’m intrigued by the border lands of sanity, and often feel that a large proportion of our fragile human race are seriously crazy. Their loopiness (and maybe my own-am I crazy too) is fascinating because they clearly cope well enough in ordinary life not to be locked up, but if being insane means they have a seriously slanted view of reality, then they must be a few sandwiches short of a picnic.

Do you want to be a ‘spot paganism in Catholicism’ loony? All you need to do is find some sort of similarity between a pagan religion and Catholicism. The Egyptians worshipped the sun god, so its easy to see how the rising Son of God in Catholicism is really paganism right? Dagon’s priests wore pointy hats so the bishop’s mitre must have come from that. You don’t need any real scholarship or any thing so objective as a fact because the real facts, of course, were covered up by the all powerful Catholic authorities. Pagans had mother godesses so Catholic veneration of the Blessed Virgin Mary shows that Catholicism is just the old pagan Earth mother worship.

The curious thing about conspiracy theories is that they usually do contain some truth. That’s why they’re intriguing. There’s just enough truth mixed with innuendo and half truths to make you say, “By gosh, I think they’re on to something! Maybe the twin towers really did explode from the inside just before the planes hit!!”

So it is with Catholicism. It was not a secret that the early church picked up certain pagan practices and dates and baptised them. It was part of their missionary strategy to build churches over the old pagan sites, and transform what was useable from the old religion. The links with the old religion are everywhere in Catholicism, and if you want to get rid of them you’d better join the Jehovah’s Witnesses. That’s why they don’t have crosses (its really the Egyptian ‘tau’ sign you know) and they don’t celebrate Christmas (its really the ancient winter solstice celebration…)

On a deeper level, the fact that Christianity has similarities to paganism is a mark of it’s authenticity, not a mark of its being a fraud. If the Christian message is true, you would expect it to connect with everything else that is true. It will therefore connect with certain elements of all the other world religions. More than that–it fulfills all the other world religions. Just as Judaism is completed and amplified by the New Covenant, so Christianity completes and amplifies all the world religions that went before it.

Does the bishop’s mitre really, really descend from the headgear of the ancient preists of Dagon? I doubt it very much, (here’s the true lowdown) but even if some scholar uncovered an ancient manuscript tomorrow in which Pope Whathisname in the second century said, “Brothers and sisters, since we follow ICTHUS the fish, let us adopt the ritual headgear of Dagon” there wouldn’t be a problem. We’d just say, “Well praise the Lord for that, we don’t worship any old fish god anymore. Neither do we worship the bishop, but isn’t it kinda neat that they thought to hook up with what went before?”

About Fr. Dwight Longenecker
  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/13669565372315999650 Jeffrey Smith

    I believe it evolved from a Byzantine court headdress, but the word mitre may have come from the Persian royal crown, the “mitra”. Any resemblance to the fish’s mouth in the picture is purely coincidental. Good post.

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/06624317806947588259 Rachel Gray

    It’s a good point that even if a few details were stolen from paganism… so what?

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/02284165373991543203 + Alan

    Definitely glad you went down this path Father. I see too many Catholics who want to defend the Church so much that they will come up with their own internal “conspiracy theories” in the reverse. They will try too hard to say that something isn’t true and in doing so, they actually help those who are trying to discredit the Church. This is unfortunate. So, if someone comes up to us and says “Christmas was a pagan day of worship” – we can say “uh, OK, and the Church did a great job of bringing that culture and those people into the Faith didn’t they?” So what if it was a fish god head. ha! If by saying this, someone is trying to say (and they are) that the Catholic Church secretly still worships dragons, or the sun, or Ishtar, oh my – well, it’s a bad way to go about discrediting something. Hit doctrines head-on if you want, but don’t try to dig up secret plots.

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/09356738924839809045 Andrew

    Talking about mitres, I recall a certain priest promising to celebrate a certain Eastern Rite Divine Liturgy. How’s that going, Father?

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/12373317560249811006 Fr. Dwight Longenecker

    I will be celebrating the Divine Liturgy for the Maronites again on Sunday. I will nag them to send the photos for me to put up on the blog.

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/11277057132720569896 Moonshadow

    This collection of articles concerning the pagan influence on church architecture is jaw-dropping, listed here in order of decreasing relevance. I recommend you sit down first …“Female Sex Signs in Churches”“The Anatomy of a Church – Part 2″“The Anatomy of a Church – Part I”

  • Pingback: Is Catholicism Pagan?


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X