Checklist for Anglican Tiber Swimming

In 1994 I was an Anglican priest on the Isle of Wight. I had a wife and two young children. We lived in a beautiful Victorian vicarage in the country. I had two beautiful Norman churches to look after. (Brading Church pictured above)

My church was growing. My congregation were loving and kind. I wanted to stay there forever. Then the Church of England pulled the rug out from under me, and I began to plan a big adventure: swimming the Tiber.

Here’s some advice for Anglican priests who are now in the situation I was in then. If you’re an Anglican reading this, forward the post, put it on your blog, add a link, spread the news.
1. If you’re thinking of coming home to Rome make sure you know why you’re doing it. Dislike of women clergy isn’t enough. 
The women bishops crisis should be causing you to examine the real status of the Anglican Church and the real claims of the Catholic Church. 
2. Read Eamon Duffy, Christopher Haigh and Jack Scarisbrick to really understand what happened in the sixteenth century. 
3. Practice your wave walking. You’re going to have to step out of your little family fishing boat and walk on the waves for a bit. The weather is stormy. You’ll probably both sink and swim, but you’ll feel great because you’re going with Peter, and once you’ve been hauled aboard the barque of Peter you’ll be home.
4. Network with others who are thinking of leaving. Encourage each other. Don’t feed your illusions about the Anglican Church. Think clearly. Speak clearly and do not be afraid. Network with those who took the step last time around. Make contacts in the Catholic Church.
5. Get in touch with the St Barnabas Society. They’ve been helping clergy converts for over a hundred years. I used to work for them. They have the resources to help you. They have former Anglican priests on their staff who work as pastoral advisors. They will never pressure you. They offer advice in total confidence.
6. You’re going to be one of God’s great gifts to the Catholic Church. Unfortunately, not all Catholics (including a good number of the English bishops) believe this. Be prepared for the fact that some Catholics will not welcome you with open arms.
7. Don’t come to the Catholic Church with conditions. Don’t expect instant ordination. Don’t expect anything except to be humbly received and begin life as a Catholic layman. A friend of mine who was a former Protestant pastor was a Catholic for two years, and after sitting in the pew patiently his pastor said, ‘I’ve got a job I’d like you to do…” “Yes father?” “Would you run the Bingo on the second Tuesday of the month?…”
8. If you’re applying to be ordained, to see a bishop, for a dispensation from the vow of celibacy, for a job… be patient. They don’t call Rome ‘the eternal city’ for nothing.
9. Be prepared for a huge outpouring of grace in your life. Anglo Catholicism is wonderful, but the the reality, the truth, the fullness and the glory of the Catholic Church will almost be tangible as you take this step of faith.
10. Be prepared for the English Catholic Church. We have liberals in the Catholic Church too. Be prepared to be suspected of being a misogynistic crank. Be prepared to be misunderstood and marginalized.
11. You may have to give up beautiful vestments, beautiful music, beautiful buildings, beautiful liturgy. The Catholic Church in England is, in many ways, still an underground church of immigrants, the poor, the dispossessed, the scorned and the marginalized. Cheer up! You’re moving from a boring established church to being part of the greatest subversive, underground revolutionary movement the world has ever seen.
12. Trust in God. I wish I could tell you my whole story, but I promise you, if you step out in faith God will not let you down. In the end no sacrifice for him and for his kingdom goes unrewarded. Your courage, your step of faith will inspire others. It will unlock graces in the world that you cannot now see. Are you concerned for your faithful people? That is beautiful, but when they see you step out in faith and give all for Christ they will be so amazed and enraged and disturbed and inspired that they will never forget it.
SPECIAL OFFER: For any bona fide Anglican priest who writes and asks, I will arrange a free copy of my book The Path to Rome–Modern Journeys to the Catholic Faith. Just drop me an email.
"Catholicism has always defined the ideal but there are no limits on God's mercy and ..."

Tony Palmer: Is There Salvation Outside ..."
"With all due respect, Shaun, are you relegating the actual Faith to whatever the local ..."

Notes on Tony Palmer’s Funeral
"There are good parking valets and bad parking valets. There are good housesitters and bad ..."

The Case for Conversion to Catholicism
"did you vote for Bush Fr Longenecker? would you have?"

Understanding Iraq

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Today, we have Bishop Edwin Barnes speaking about “friends in the Roman Communion”: don’t know what “The Church Union” is, but it seems to me that something is REALLY happening.

  • That’s a useful checklist for adult converts, in general, whether anglican ordained or not.

  • Fr. Longenecker: Did you mean to refer to the “Anglican Catholic Church” in #9 on your checklist? Perhaps this was inadvertent. Anyway, this checklist is excellent. I second the recommendation of Duffy’s The Stripping of the Altars and J. J. Scarisbrick’s The Reformation and the English People. I would also recommend Aidan Nichols’ splendid book, The Panther and the Hind (the seeds of the present corruptions were sown at the very beginning of the protestant “Church of England”). I might also suggest Hilaire Belloc’s How the Reformation Happened and G. K. Chesterton’s The Well and the Shallows. Helpful conversion narratives are Ronald Knox’s A Spiritual Aeneid, R. H. Benson’s Confessions of a Convert, and Newman’s Apologia Pro Vita Sua. Every faithful Catholic should rejoice over anyone who, accepting the claims of the Catholic Church, asks to be received into the Church. Certainly we should all pray for the conversion of England, once known as the Dowry of Mary.

  • For those on the other side of the pond who are swimming the Tiber, be sure to connect with the Coming Home Network in Ohio. They sponsor ‘Journey Home’ on EWTN and provide the same assistance in the US as the society mentioned in the UK. Web addy:

  • AngloCatholics ought be confident that a fondness for choral music is very en vogue globally among RCs – as I remarked in this thread at Amy’s a couple of months ago: at have an Anglican Public School chaplain Gerald Moultrie to thank for the “poetic-englishing” of my favorite hymn There is sure to be another Keur Moussa out there no? wish the Church many happy returns from all the corners of the British Commonwealth (and apropos that topic, AngloCatholics need to gen-up on recent scholarship in economics that critiques the Tory-AdamSmith-“Wealth of Nations” mercantilism-masquerading-as-capitalism I referenced re: the 17thC Salamanca and 19thC Austrian schools in the aforementioned thread) Cheerio chumsClare Krishan

  • …there’s sure to be another Keur Moussa gem of a community out there waiting to sing the praises of our Lord in harmony with Solemnes chants of old

  • “They don’t call Rome ‘the eternal city’ for nothing.”Ha! Nicely put.