“Pilgrim” just has a much nicer ring to most eyes than “puritan.” On one level, the Pilgrims (who didn’t become the Pilgrims until the early nineteenth century) receive far more attention than they deserve. Every November, school children and many other Americans hear about the brave band of religious refugees who stepped onto Plymouth Rock and then celebrated a First Thanksgiving. The reality is rather more disappointing. The band was brave, but the rock is tiny and the thanksgiving wasn’t... Read more