Whiteness, Privilege, and Intersectionality

Whiteness, Privilege, and Intersectionality September 21, 2019

I shared something a while back that led to me having a conversation with another white American male, one whose late wife was African-American and who has a child that is thus considered “black” in the American imposition of racist binaries. The conversation was about the idea and the terminology of white privilege. As our conversation proceeded, I very much started to grasp his perspective on what he found problematic about the terminology, in particular that privilege is not something that someone can simply divest themselves of individually. The only way to eliminate privilege is for all to gain what only some now have, at which point privilege of that particular sort is reduced or eliminated.

I’ve found myself thinking a lot about intersectionality because it relates not only to that present-day matter, but also ancient followers of Jesus like Joanna, who may have had significant wealth and status, but was probably despised by some because of her connection with Herod’s household, as well as not having the same opportunities that males of her status and background had. That is the heart of the matter. Privilege doesn’t mean everything is easy. Privilege means that some are disadvantaged in ways that you are not, that you lack a disadvantage others have. If you are white and poor, or rich and hated, it may not feel like privilege. Perhaps we need better terminology. But for the moment, what we need is to help people understand how something like privilege can be multifaceted and complex.

Here are some links related to this topic, interspersed with further thoughts generated by them and/or my conversation.

I Wanted to Know What White Men Thought About Their Privilege. So I Asked.

Pastor Daniel Hill talking about the church and white supremacy

Whiteness, religion, and modernity

Let’s Discuss: Some IM Statements about Culture

Talking about Privilege with Nuance by Elise M. Edwards

Ralph Eubanks, “What Makes Me Black? What Makes You White?”

Kyle Korver on White Privilege

Yaa Gyasi’s article about whether she, a Ghanian immigrant to America, is “black” is worth reading.

Racism is morally toxic even while it is economically advantageous to some. Thinking about this led me to realize that racism doesn’t only harm those who are discriminated against. It actually does not benefit anyone, in at least one important sense. It may benefit specific individuals in specific cases where discrimination occurs, but it is on the whole to the detriment of society and brings negative consequences that impact everyone. Perhaps we should focus more attention on that point than we have tended to?

Is the privilege that comes with whiteness a bad thing that we need to eliminate, or a good thing that we need to spread to others? If all have it, then the term “privilege” ceases to apply.

My conversation partner posed an interesting question, offering me a hypothetical situation in which I can see one of the following two miracles occur in the world – prejudice disappears, or socioeconomic disadvantages that reflect past prejudice disappear. Which would you choose? Which would have the longer-term impact?

A good end point in our conversation was to emphasize something that certain ways of phrasing the matter can fail to convey: the aim is not to take something good away from whites, but to take something bad away from society.

David Fitch, James Cone: Liberation Theology 1

What racism is and how to organize against it

Americans are divided by their views on race

“White Evangelicals Are The Most Fragile Of All White People”

Whiteness as Default in a Majority Minority Nation

Whiteness is not the plumbline

What Is a Racist?

If Mass Poverty is Declining, Why should We Worry about High Inequality?

Evangelical Shift #4

How I Finally Came to Understand My White Privilege

THE HISTORY AND POLITICS OF WHITE IDENTITY

It’s a Wonderful Life: Social Justice Warrior Version

Social Justice and the Gospel

A time of privilege

White privilege in NZ

Privilege and Lies: Some Problematic Myths about Vocation

Why It’s So Hard To Talk About Racism

Carlson calling out white privilege

"So what if Martin Luther said that? Your shoddy reasoning in your comments here isn’t ..."

Duel of the Antichrists
"So enlighten us, where in the entire country have property taxes not "gone through the ..."

Duel of the Antichrists
"No. Pretty sure the Trib wasn't conservative even before 2016.You'd love living in Chicago if ..."

Duel of the Antichrists
"The biggest mistake today's would-be prophets make is they assume that Revelation is in chronological ..."

Duel of the Antichrists

Browse Our Archives