Proud White Hindu?

I recently shared an article about Nikki Haley (who I have since learned is the US Ambassador to the UN. Yes, I didn’t know that. I’m ashamed) and whether she claims to be white or changes back and forth about being white or Indian. I don’t know whether the article is accurate but I thought it brought up some interesting questions, particularly around how long we are supposed to identify with the ethnic identities of our ancestors. But anyway, that is not what this post is about.

One commenter said everyone here is following someone who is a “proud white Hindu.”

That startled me. Am I a proud white Hindu? I’m proud to be a Hindu. I’m proud that I have found the path that works for me and leads me ever closer to peace, bliss, and Truth. I’m proud of everything Hinduism has to offer the world.

But I’m not proud to be white.

IMG_1084
Proud of my makeup? Sure. But my coloring is just how I was born.

Whiteness is not a thing to be proud of or ashamed of. It’s not a value judgement. It’s a category that I happen to fit in based on my skin tone and my ethnic heritage in my current society. It’s a factual statement and not about better or worse.

This is a misunderstanding I have been trying to clear up since the blog first started eight years ago. Over these years I have learned that many people do seem to attach a value judgement to whiteness. Some people think white people are better (this is so horrifying but in the age of Trump one cannot deny that some people think this), some people think paler skin equates with virtue and beauty, some people think whiteness is bad because white people were colonizers, some people are afraid that Indians have been so brainwashed by white colonizers that they take a white person more seriously. So much baggage connected to the color of one’s skin.

When I say I am a white Hindu, I mean none of that. People seem to assume I’m trying to say I’m better in some way. What I actually mean and what I have always meant is that my ethnic background is different from the majority of people in my religion and that leads me to have experiences, thoughts, and questions that native Indian Hindus might not. Hence I write about Hinduism primarily from the perspective of culture and community.

I am not proud of being white because white is just a skin color. It is not good and it is not bad. Some people also accuse me of being ashamed of my skin color. That is equally absurd. I just don’t think that skin is a thing to hold pride about. Except when I do a good job clearing up my acne. Then I’m proud of my skin.

In some ways I do regret that I named my blog as I did. On the other hand, it certainly draws attention. And it’s easy to find me. If you tell someone to look up “white Hindu” they are certain to find me. It gets people worked up. I did not expect that when I first named this blog. But it’s been eight years and I feel that this is my blog’s identity and this is what it will stay. How would you know it was me if I wrote under a different title? And so I will have to continue to field questions every day about why I’m making this about race, why I’m being racist, why I’m setting myself apart from other Hindus. I do not believe that I am doing any of those things but it certainly highlights something about our cultures and lives that using an accurate descriptor of my skin tone can cause such unrest.

New to this blog? Check out these posts:

What Makes Me A Hindu?

Did I Start Out Christian?

Why Am I Called “The White Hindu”?

New to Hinduism? Learn more here:

Hinduism 101: What Do Hindus Believe?

Can I Convert To Hinduism?

Your First Visit To A Hindu Temple

Super Simple Daily Puja

—-

Thank you to my wonderful Patreon supporters…

  • Brian Hanechak
  • Amit Agarwal
  • Don Moir

(views expressed here are mine alone and do not reflect opinions of my supporters. Links within the text may be affiliate links, meaning that if you purchase something I get a small commission for recommending it. I only recommend things I truly believe in)

new patreon ad for blog

Become a Patron!

"http://astrahealth.olanola.comhttp://astrahealth.eklablog..."

Toys vs Sacred Objects
"http://www.call-girl-in-pat..."

Toys vs Sacred Objects
"female escorts in patna"

Toys vs Sacred Objects
""I was circling around, trying to see if there was an unlocked window to get ..."

What Indians Need To Know About ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Ayla

    Namaste Ambaa, I have been absent from the blog for (well..) years. I want to get caught up, but thats not the point of my comment. I recently found out that I actually have Indian in my ancestry, and I am “white” like you. But my point is that, like in your post; skin color is just that. Skin color. It just is. And to me, it doesn’t matter, what your race, class, gender ect is. Like you (and probably many other Hindu’s out there), I believe that all the Gods and Goddesses want, is your worship, your devotion and love. It doesn’t matter if you are rich or poor, they will still accept your offering (if you offer it with devotion and love). But this is just me. And I want to thank you for writing your book, the new Hindu toolbox. I love that you put assignments, and I am doing them. I had a couple questions though

    1) When I get around to creating my alter, I know the space needs to be clean; but what about the rest of the house? Not to say that my house is, or is not. But I can’t find anything regarding this. My google fu is not up to this task, LOL!

    2) In your travel alter post, you mentioned drawing the Ganesha on, I want to do the same thing for Gods like Shiva and Kali and others, but where did you look for “Simplified” images of these Deities.

    3) are you still doing the Hindu movie “club”?

    Thanks for all you have done and continue to do, as always. 😀

    • Ambaa Choate

      So good to have you back! The years fly by so quickly, don’t they? I have struggled to keep up with writing the blog. I have a toddler now and I’m pregnant with a second baby, so it’s quite exhausting.

      As to your questions:
      1) I think it is best to keep the whole house clean. Kind of like how we take off our shoes when entering the home and not just the altar room. The whole house becomes a sacred space when it has an altar in it. Not that I’m great at doing this. I take the opportunity of events like Navratri to really scrub my space clean!
      2) I kind of just made it up. I looked at a lot of images and tried to see what was the simplest way to convey the shape of Sri Ganesha. You could try tracing over some more complex images? Or print out images to use instead of drawing them?
      3) No, we haven’t been watching movies in a while!

    • kartashok

      Sanatana Dharma is an ethno-racial religion that was created specifically by the cultural AND racial merging of the Central Asian-Aryan, Elamo-Dravidian and Australoid peoples of the Indian subcontinent’s north and northwest starting in 2000 BC. It has little to do with the Celtic and Teutonic warriors of Europe, as those beliefs branched away from each other over 5000 years ago in the Proto-Indo-European homeland in Russia.
      Your culture is Odinism (or Wotanism). Or Celtic mythology.

      • Ambaa

        You must be a universalist if you think equal Truth is found in Celtic mythology.

        • kartashok

          No, I am Volkish. Celts can find truth by adhering to Celtic mythology, Germanics by Germanic mythology, Slavic by Rodnovery, and biological Indians through Hinduism. Your truth is not our truth, your race is not our race, and your species is not our species, you have nothing in common with us biologically. Stick to your own religion and stop co-opting mine.

          • Ambaa

            I am sorry that you feel that I am co-opting your religion. I do what I can to approach it with humbleness and respect. I support and raise up native Hindus and Indians as often as possible. But I just find your argument that we are a different species completely impossible to take seriously. We have an enormous amount in common biologically. I mean, apes only have a few chromosomes different from humans. Humans are pretty much biologically identical.

            I am sorry too that the world has a history of oppression from white people. I do my best to dismantel that and I know that you are not willing to accept that I sincerely want to heal racial tension and pull back as a white person to let people of other colors have more power and control in the world. I regret deeply what my ancestors did. It is heartbreaking to know that you think I am repeating those mistakes.

          • kartashok

            Look, this is not about you. This is about group dynamics, not individuals. You are not Indian and not wanted as a member of our tribal faith. Just as white people want “sh!tskins” like me to be exterminated, as I was told growing up in the United States and as you can see in this very website, I want YOUR people to leave our culture and our way of life alone and not call yourself Hindu. It’s the least you could do. This is not about the past, this is about the present and future of our own kind. http://www.patheos.com/blogs/andygill/american-christianity-is-white-supremacy/
            Now that I’m back in India, I hate you pig skins and hope the Jews and others get together and have a go against you once and for all.

          • phillyaggie

            You might be better off mentally to go back to Tamil Nadu, turn off the Internet, and live the pure life of a Tam-Brahm Shaivite. I think you may be on to something here. You living the dharma as you see fit will be very respectful.

          • kartashok

            Turning off the internet would amount to a return to savagery. My Aryan heritage demands that I use the technology of both my own people and of aliens to bring about value to my people.
            And who are you to tell me what to do within my country?

          • phillyaggie

            As it is, Tamil Nadu is being overrun by Christian proselytizers. We’re losing even Tamil Brahmin families to ChristoIslam. It would do wonders to have someone like you live there, to protect dharma, to propagate the purity of it… You should definitely think of moving to Tamil Nadu. Do it!

          • kartashok

            I’m a Tamil Brahmin. I have several acres of farmland in my family’s name in Tamil Nadu, although because of India’s socialist government (and because I’m still only in my twenties), I am not allowed to own agricultural land in my own homeland, so I live in Mumbai where the jobs and money is. I love the Marathi people and I’m dating a Marathi girl. Either way, I do spend my winters in Tamil Nadu, and would love to protect dharma.

          • kartashok

            As a Brahmin, if I wanted to call myself a Celtic Druid and visited Scotland, a Scottish skinhead would probably beat me dead to a pulp, just have a little think about that. It’s not about people of color wanting power or control, it’s about working class and middle class white people ABUSING their powers today.

        • Anonymouse

          All I know, Carolyn “Eastern Philosopher”® Choate, is that your forefathers defecated in the mouth of THEIR forefathers, once the PADRE came calling with the Gospels (or whatever).

          Your people have lost their virginity. Mine hasn’t. You can virginity only once, and after that, it really doesn’t matter.

          We do not want to mix with spiritual/religious promiscuous sluts.

          Please leave us.

          P.S. Once a traitor, always a traitor.

      • disqus_kl7kY8xctR

        Lmao did this dude just say that there is no biological commonality across races?? Ok.

        • kartashok

          There are huge differences in IQ, bacteria levels, skull shapes, brain size, hair texture, etc. between the races. That’s why race-specific biological weapons have already been created by the US government and by Israel. If all races were the same as liberal and cuckservatives say, bioweapons wouldn’t be a thing we have to worry about.

    • Ambaa

      I’m so glad you’re back! I am often absent from my own blog 🙁 Life gets busy! lol.

      1) I’m not sure, but I think the altar space is the most important to worry about first. They do say that Lakshmi loves a clean home and will bless people with clean houses!
      2) I believe I searched for clip art images and did a lot of scrolling!
      3) I have not been doing the Bollywood movie club. At this point I’m barely getting posts out, unfortunately. I now have a toddler and I’m pregnant so I’m quite exhausted!

  • Anonymouse

    Carolyn Choate,

    I’ll be glad to tell you that your fellow Irish Catholic, Jeffery D. Long, who also makes a laughable claim that he is a Hindu and has a acquired an ethnic Hindu wife for gaining legitimacy, lives in the city of Elizabethtown, PA, a town that is 96.32% white as per the US Census ‘2000. I wonder why is this need for gated communities in exclusive ZIP codes???

    People are like bruhaha about the “Hindu caste system”, but the Brahmin lived in the same village, in the same neighborhood, and indeed in the same street as a fisherman for thousands of years; and although many might not have personally touched a fisherman, they refused seek a different social life.

    There was never a “Brahmin flight” or “Kshatriya flight”. Au contraire, “White flight” was and is a living thing.

    When the Rajputs built their magnificent fortress cities in the deserts of Rajasthan during the middle ages, everyone was allowed inside. Compare that with White-only hospitals and restrooms in Alabama in living memories.

    When the Saurashrians were driven out of their homes by Mahmud of Ghazni, it was the Tamil kings of the Chola Dynasty that gave them refuge.

    A thousand (yes, a THOUSAND) years before the involuntary dismantling of the South African apartheid, the great Vaishnavite theologian and philosopher Ramanuja hugged an untouchable whom he recognized as wiser than himself, and invited him to his home for lunch.

    And in the sixteen century, when Chaitanya Mahaprabhu was speaking of the divinity of all humans, YOUR Roman Catholic Church was seriously pontificating on whether Indigenous Americans have souls or not!!!

    We Hindus have our own ethno-cultural ethos which is MUTUALLY INCOMPATIBLE with the Western ethno-cultural ethos.

    The “Western Hindu” is a contradiction in terms. You can be born in two (quite antagonistic) Civilizations no more than you can be born in two wombs.

    It is anatomically impossible.

    To quote the poet: “Oh, East is East, and West is West, and never the twain shall meet”

    • Agni Ashwin

      Why is Long not a Hindu?

      • Anonymouse

        I suppose you are EITHER a non-Hindu OR a rootless, soulless, Westernized Hindu.

        Hinduism is a religion AND an ethnicity, and they are inseparable.

        Long is not ethnically Hindu, which means he’s not a Hindu. Is that too difficult to understand???

        Jeffery Long and Carolyn Choate are anti-Hindus who want to destroy the Hindu ethnicity by proselytizing the evil creed that says that the Hindu religion is separate from the Hindu ethnicity.

        THIS IS GENOCIDE.

        • Agni Ashwin

          So, Long’s children might be Hindu, but Long himself cannot be?

          • Anonymouse

            I can understand your muddled conception of the word “ethnicity” given that you are the product of a culture where a Pashtun tribesman and a Japanese sumo wrestler are alleged to share an “Asian” “ethnicity”.

            Long’s children are Anglo-Indian, in other words, NOT HINDU. Long is an Irish (Catholic), in other words, NOT HINDU.

            None of them are Hindu.

          • Shridas

            “Anglo Indians” are a particular ethnicity in India. They have a long history, especially in Bengal. I suppose Long’s kids may be called something else. But you make some interesting points. Rajiv Malhotra and many other Indian Hindus are trying to convince western yoga practitioners to identify as Hindu. They actually criticize westerners who practice yoga, pranayama, meditation, do kirtan, etc but do not claim to be Hindu as “U-turners” and “traitors. Your concept of Hindu being an ethnicity that one must be born into is one that has been familiar and common to me. This new trend with desis like Malhotra and others actually desiring non-Indians to claim Hinduism is new and strange. Not saying I think its wrong, it just appears to be a new development. Malhotra also lives in a gated New Jersey community, so there’s that.

          • Anonymouse

            “Shridas”,

            As I have said before, I suppose you are EITHER a non-Hindu OR a rootless, soulless, Westernized Hindu.

            Just try to enter Puri Jagannath Temple and I’ll see how Hindu “You” or “Jeffery Long” or Jeffery Long’s mongrel offspring or Carolyn Choate or “Agni Ashwin” are……..

            No amount of sprinkling of “Holy Water” or declaration of “Faith” (whatever that is supposed to mean) can turn a Mlechchha into Arya.

          • Shridas

            Not every desi Hindu is allowed in Jagannath Mandir either. Could be the original gated community. 😉

          • Zakariya Ali Sher

            And when I was living in Indonesia, I actually knew a Hindu friend who was turned away from Puri Jagannath Temple. They were Balinese, not Indian, but their family had been practising Hinduism for thousands of years. In fact, Bali is mostly a Hindu island. Indeed, Hinduism was once widespread across Cambodia, Vietnam, Thailand, Burma, the Philippines and various other Indonesian islands. Are you going to tell me that Hinduism never accepted converts? Or that such people aren’t Hindus today? Clearly they think they are, and practice their own rituals, maintain their own temples, etc.

          • kartashok

            They are wastes of space. Hinduism never had converts. Whenever a tribe accepted Hinduism, they had a Hindu patriarch who imparted it to them by creating offspring with them at some point. Including the Balinese and other Southeast Asians thousands of years ago. The modern day chink mixed Southeast Asians have only been there since recently, less than 900 years. Most Indians LOVE the Balinese, they are our brothers.

          • Anonymouse

            Indonesian Hindus almost completely assimilated into our civilization. They have a glorious Hindu history e.g. The Majapahit Empire. They are a qualitatively different case than Eastern Philosophers.

            BTW, why is a Mumin like you rooting for Kufr rather than Islam? I smell something fishy.

          • kartashok

            Practicing some fag “exercise-yoga” doesn’t make some Celtic-Teutonic warmongerer demon into a Hindu.

          • Zakariya Ali Sher

            Haha, no, if Jeffrey Long is an Irish Catholic, then he wouldn’t be “Anglo” anything. I suppose you’d have to call them “Hiberno-Indian,” given that Irish are a separate culture from English, just as Bengalis are a separate culture from Tamils. Also most English aren’t Catholic. You’d probably find this amusing but their king explicitly broke from the Catholic Church centuries ago over the issue of divorcing his wife.

          • kartashok

            They’re all Celtic-Germanic and imperialist. They are not even the same species as Asians, they have higher rates of Neanderthal and Homo Heidelbergensis DNA.

          • Anonymouse

            Irish Catholics are among the most clannish and ethnocentric species to have ever existed on this planet. We don’t want their baggage and Western baggage, generally, to sully our culture.

            Does that make sense?

          • kartashok

            Thank you. It is the Scots-Irish who founded the KKK and practice the lion’s share of what we could call “redneck racism” in the US against anyone different from them.

          • Anonymouse

            Another thing, Henry VIII was no Irish Catholic. And, I doubt he had any love lost for them.

          • kartashok

            Long’s children are MIXED BREED MUD BLOODS THAT SHOULD BE CURB STOMPED. Not Hindus. Hindu women breeds with her white master and pops out identity-less hybrid subhumans. And Hindus are supposed to claim them? This is colonial cuckoldry.

          • Ambaa

            I weep for how far you have to go to recover from your hurt. This anger and hatred will only continue to hurt you. To say such things about children is heartbreaking. The divine is present in everything, even a dog. So of course God is in white people and brown people and everyone in between. That does not mean that I want to see white people take over Hinduism. We come to be humble, to strive closer to samadhi. You cannot take Hinduism away from me by using vile and disgusting language. All I feel is pity.

          • kartashok

            God is not in R1B whites. Russians and Ukrainians, Avestan Iranians, Mitannis, Hittites and other R1A white Aryans have a soul, and have a cultural commonality as Easterners with us and the Indo-Aryans who codified Hinduism around 1500 BC. Celtic-Germanic-Latin people have nothing in common with us though, the Haplogroup R1B was probably created by some alien admixture. Our God is not and NEVER will be in you. You will never be a Hindu, just as a pig born in a horse’s barn will never be a horse, you will always be a mleccha. Our Lord Shiva of the Indus Valley deals with people who have Elamo-Dravidian admixture, no one else. And whites are the ones who fed black and brown babies to alligators in Amerikkka, you’re the baby killers. Killing babies for the color of their skin is something that gives your evil kind a special kind of pleasure, and then you try to act high and mighty about “human rights”.

          • Ch Billy

            kartashok, Anonymouse, If you guys want to be really authentic about Indianness, then let me put it bluntly. Indian worldview has nothing to do with ethnicity, zilch. Of course there is an idea of identity in Hinduism. But that identity was never ever based on ethnicity. Ethnicity as a concept was alien to Indians unless Europeans and middle easterners drove it into the minds of Indians. A case in example is the Srimad Bhagavatam canto 2, chapter 4, verse 18 which says:
            kirāta-hūṇāndhra-pulinda-pulkaśā
            ābhīra-śumbhā yavanāḥ khasādayaḥ
            ye ‘nye ca pāpā yad-apāśrayāśrayāḥ
            śudhyanti tasmai prabhaviṣṇave namaḥ

            Translation: Members of the Kirāta, Hūṇa, Āndhra, Pulinda, Pulkaśa, Ābhīra, Śumbha, Yavana and Khasa races and even others can be purified by taking shelter of the devotees of the Lord, due to His being the supreme power. I beg to offer my respectful obeisances unto Him.

            Kirata: Aboriginal tribes of Bihar in India.
            Huna: The people of East Germany and part of Russia
            Āndhra: The tribal people of Andhra Pradesh, India
            Pulinda: The Greeks. Greece was under Pandavas during Mahabharata.
            Pulkasa: The tribal inhabitants of Vindhyas, India
            Abhira: The people of the region starting from Sind to North Africa (Pakistan, Afghanistan, Central Asia, Middle East and North Africa). Middle east was also under Pandavas during the Mahabharata.
            Sumbhas or Kankas: The people of Kanka province of ancient India (probably tribal people). This cannot be traced to modern India.
            Yavana: The people of Europe although sometimes it may mean only people of modern day Turkey and a little beyond upto Italy. Turkey and Europe was also under the Pandavas during the Mahabharata (after Kurukshetra) and they took part in Kurukshetra some on the side of Pandavas and some on the side of Kauravas.
            Khasa: The people of Mongolia, China, Japan, Korea and Taiwan (East Asia)

            The tribes in Indian subcontinent are mentioned here because they were outside the vedic culture. Also, it should be noted that at the time of Mahabharata, entire South East Asia was part o f India or Bharata. In fact, the name Indonesia literally means islands of India and Hindu culture is dominant in that country to this day. So is it in Indo-China and Malaysia-Singapore. Traces of Hindu culture can be found in Philippines too. Vietnam was once Hindu and even today, there are Hindu practitioners there.

            The most important observation above is that the various tribal cultures within India, the whites of Europe, the semi-whites of Middle East and North Africa, and finally, the East Aisnas were all considered melchcha cultures or “outside Vedic” cultures and yet, it was clearly mentioned that they have the same authority to learn Vedic scriptures and adopt Hinduism (or Vaishnavism in this case). So, you can see that the Indians did not have a sense of ethnicity cause Indian tribals with Indian ethnicity were treated same as tribals in Europe with White ethnicity.

            The sense of identity in India that is historically acknowledges are:
            1) Geographical (mountain cultures, river valley cultures, grassland cultures, people revering Ganga in North, Himalayas in Nepal, Godavari in central India, Kaveri in Southern india etc.)
            2) Culture/philosophy (the atheistic Jains, the agnostic Buddhista, the devout Sikhs, the devout Vaishnavas, the Advaitin Smartas, the Kashmir Shaivites, the Bengal Shakta, the Kerala Shaktas, the Karntaka Shaivites, the Uttaranchali Shiavites, the Bengal/Gaudiya Vaishnavites etc.)
            3) Genetic (based on Gotra/Kula/Jati and this does not have anything to do with ethnicity but only with family lineage)

            When we talk of Indian identity, we should stick to these things. None of these sense of identities gives us license to discriminate people of any other ethnicity like for example Ambaa Choate is an Advaitin. For a non-Advaitin, she might be an outsider. But for an Indian who is Advaitin, she is more an insider than any of you two i.e., Anonymouse and kartashok considering it is possible that neither of you may be Advaitin. I would strongly advise you two to not invent strange things like ethnocentrism and claim it belongs to Indian culture whereas in reality such things did not exist originally and were forced down our throats by colonizing invaders. It is you people who are succumbing to the white man’s narrative and bringing down our cultural value.

          • kartashok

            Europeans are biological enemies of non-Europeans, and the only good one is a dead one. Drop dead.
            Inventing ethnocentrism is the only way to protect the Indian race. Ever heard of cultural appropriation? Whites as it is claim they invented everything under the sun, don’t give them the Indus Valley Civilization. The Indian identity is ETHNICALLY connected to the Indus Valley Civilization, and anyone who says otherwise is a worthless faggot and a loser. This disgusting white slut Carolyn and this race mixer Jeffery Long are European Aryans, not Indians, and not Hindus. Hinduism wouldn’t exist without the combination of the cultures of the Devas and Asuras, the Asuras being the rulers of the Indus Valley civilization, the ancestors of every dark skinned Indian person. Even the British directly identified Hindus as the natives of the Indus River and east of it. Drop dead, you anti-Indian waste of space, death to white men, women and children. God bless Rothschild for white genocide, the sooner the better.

          • Ch Billy

            kartashok, I will ignore the abuses you hurled at me and will not return anything because, unlike you, I am a Vaishnava Sadhaka and I will not give in to such Sanskaras.

            You are definitely a troll and/or a brainwashed Dravidian race theorist who is parading oneself as a Dharmic practitioner. You are mouthing all those things which the Dharmic people have been scholarly debating and dismissing for decades now. Most of the theories you are presenting here were invented during the time of G. U. Pope and Max Mueller who have themselves admitted that they INVENTED these narratives to weaken the native mind so that they fall in line with Christianity. This is not even a contested thing because there is physical evidence in the form of letters and testimonials from family members regarding their confessions.

            Let us begin with the ludicrous Aryan Invasion theory you are alluding to here. The Aryan Invasion theory has been debunked literally decades ago and if you say Aryan Invasion in any respected humanities department in the world, you will be fired for your ignorance and bigotry. There is literally no archaeological evidence or evidence in the form of mass graves or mutilated dead bodies on a large scale of people killed in war to prove any sort of invasion whatsoever. The ENTIRE WORLD has moved away from Aryan Invasion to Aryan Migration theory and you are still stuck in a time capsule it seems.

            The Yavanas are mentioned in the Mahabharata including the distance in Yojanas that they came from which clearly indicates Greece. If you dismiss Mahabharata as mythology, you will be facing real difficulties as the geography of every region within India including the South and Northeast both in Ramayana and Mahabharata are clearly factual as these regions and geographical features still exist. To accept those geographical facts mentioned in the Itihasas within India and to deny those geographical facts away from India is a part of the game called selective bias to demean and denigrate Dharmic scriptures by European ideologues so that Indians feel inferior about themselves. You clearly have bought into these theories without reading the Itihasas and verifying how they have been interpreted assuming that if Europeans are saying this they must be right. This is the sort of inferiority complex and insecurity phenomenon that gave rise to the ludicrous Dravidian theories that you are presenting here. Mahabharata is dated by European historians to be from 8th or 9th century BC or latest from 400 BC when it was finalized in its current form. Alexander was there between 356 and 323 BC. So, your claim of Yavanas being there only after Alexander’s “invasion” falls flat even in terms of the European interpretations whom you consider authentic.

            Regarding proto-indo Europeans and the farce that is associated with it, Indian history is a testament that linguistics were never associated with the culture of a people. Throughout history there were people from different geographies and different languages who shared similar culture whereas there were people with same language in same geography with vastly different culture. Tamil Nadu had Vaishnavites, Shaktas and Shaivas along with Jains who were always fighting through debates despite all of them speaking the same language and being from the same place. This Eurocentric theory of language defining culture is a distinct European experience here every country has a different language and a culture associated with it. It is quite obvious that they are projecting their ideas on India where the experience has been quite different. This is kindergarten level logic which you are denying. Sanskrit was the origin of all Indo-European languages and Sanskrit originated in India. Yes, I strongly lean towards out-of-India theory. You see all the early linguists and historians clearly declared Sanskrit as the mother of all Indo-European languages due to the fact that Sanskrit is the only language that has an origin story in the scriptures, it has the most extensive grammar of all (with 10 cases) and it is the most sophisticated of all in its form and usage. This logic was deliberately broken by Max Mueller and G U Pope who strangely twisted the logic that a well-advanced language should be derivative and not original because originally man was primitive and man could not have developed such an advanced language. This distortion continues till now when they are saying Armenian is the mother of all European languages because it has a click and primitive languages should have a click!!! If this logic is not absurd, I don’t know what is. Basically, the science of linguistics as it has developed in the West is a pseudo science that is full of crazy unsubstantiated assumptions and there are many people in the world who agree with me because the Europeans have gone to different countries and dismissed their own stories of how their language is structured and replaced it with Eurocentric theories full of distortions by force. It is no wonder that even the Aryan Migration theory is hotly contested among all historians except the linguistic historians who accept Aryan Migration theory as the sole truth!!!

            Coming to Dravidians. The so-called “Dravidians” by the latest, most-reliable genetic tests have been proved to be a mixture of native hunter-gatherers and Iranian agriculturists. So, they do have foreign lineage. the only difference between them and North Indians is that North Indians have an extra addition of Ural steppe pastoralists. If at all the so-called “Dravidian” are only less foreign than “Aryans” which flies in the face of the native Dravidians theory spouted by Max Mueller, G U Pope and the biggest crook of the world called Periyar. The reality is that everyone is mixed as is expected and that is why ethnicity is such a no-go zone in all of Dharmic scriptures because in the long run ethnicity means nothing, zilch. However loud you shout, ethnicity is in no way a part of Dharmic or Indian identity and unlike you, I have solid evidences and rational thinking to back up my answer.

            Finally, the “Aryan” nonsense. You will never understand how ludicrous this is without digging deep enough which I have done. You see the Rig Veda never mentions anything like tribes or cultures. What it mentions is different realms like the heavenly realm where the Gods or Devas like Indra, Varuna and Vayu exist and the earthly realm where noble kings are bothered by evil minded people who are termed Asuras. Now, as an average person, you can interpret in two common ways. The first way is to claim that these fantastical realms are real and we are just not capable of seeing it and the second way of seeing it is that this is all mythology and they have some metaphorical meaning related to human mind, thoughts as actions. But, Max Mueller bizarrely interpreted the Devas and Asuras as different tribes on Earth which is a real red flag a lot of scholars have pointed out including Dr. B R Ambedkar in his book “Who were the Shudras?”. This sort of bizarre interpretation was done to specifically create divisions in India as was the motive of the Queen to send Max Mueller to India by Max Mueller’s own admission. The logic Max Mueller used was based on a single verse that said “while the Devas pronounced Sanskrit Vedic Mantras perfectly, the Asuras deliberately mispronounced them leading to disastrous consequences”. Now, this was cleverly interpreted as “The Devas are an Indo-Arya tribe who pronounced Sanskrit well because it was their language whereas the Asuras were Dravidians who could not pronounce Sanskrit well because they were Tamilians”. This distorted interpretation completely neglected the fact that the verse said that the Asuras DELIBERATELY mispronounced Vedic mantras. Deliberately means that they knew it and yet, did not pronounce properly. Throughout Vedic and Puranic texts the Ausras are shown to be from very high castes like Brahmanas (Ravana was a Brahmana, Hiranya Kashipu was born to Brahmana) and Kshatriyas (Shishupala was Kshatriya, Dantavakra was Kshatriya) who were very well-versed in Sanskrit and in fact so expert that they even wrote amazing Sanskrit mantras themselves like the Lankavatara Sutra of Ravana. Deliberately mispronouncing Vedic mantras causes disasters and this was done deliberately by people of Asuric minds to cause havoc in the world. This has nothing to do with tribes or languages or Dravidians etc. If you ask why Tamil is so different from Sanskrit, this is clearly established in the Dharmic scriptures. In the puranic times, there were only three languages, Prakrit (or Braja bhasha), Sanskrit and Tamil as shown in the scriptures. Tamil was invented by sage Agastya and it was clearly mentioned in the Shiva Purana that Lord Karthikeya had to learn Tamil to come and rule the place during the time of Lord Shiva. So, Tamil is indeed an ancient language no doubt by the admission of scriptures. It is just not a tribal language of the so-called original Dravidian people which is a clear foreign invention.

            My write-up is based on Rig Veda, Rajiv Malhotra’s Breaking India, Dr. Ambedkar’s Who were the Shudras?, Dr. Nagaswamy’s lecture series and Dr. Raj Vedam’s lecture series. Dr. Naga Swamy, Dr. Raj Vedam and myself are all south Indians and yet, we did not fall for this misleading “native Dravidians” farce theory because, unlike you we are not ashamed and insecure of our skin color to fall for a false narrative that falsely pits dark skin Indians against light skin Indians. We genuinely think that skin color has nothing to do with a person’s spiritual growth as was told by the rishis since time immemorial. I would also recommend you to see Michel Danino’s lecture in IIT Gandhinagar called “The Aryan Controversy” on how the dried up Saraswati river and the recent findings in Ganaga Vindhyas are very important evidence to debunk all these stupid baseless race theories that are used to brainwash Tamil people to an unimaginable extent.

          • kartashok

            I’m not a Dravidian race theorist, I am a South Indian Brahmin. I regard the R1A Aryans as being very, very different from the R1B Western Europeans. Even today, Slavs are much more honorable than their Amerinazi counterparts. You are just a Vaishnava-cuck sucking up to the most evil people from the most evil nation that has ever been known to man.

          • kartashok

            The Aryan theory is REAL snowflake. It hasn’t been “debunked” by anyone but some RSS cow piss drinkers. If you don’t believe me, go take a look at a Dardic Kashmiri or a Kalasha/Nuristani Pakistani white woman and take a look at that dalit loser b!tch Mayawati. Down South we don’t have an inferiority complex, we’re proud to be Dravidians/Meluhhas, we don’t want to go around pretending that we were once pure Aryans, we weren’t. And again, Yavanas came to mean “Ionians” or Greeks ONLY AFTER the invasion of Alexander the Great. The Mahabharata happened more than a thousand years before Alexander the Great’s invasion. So the Yavanas were modern day Pamiris/Tajiks. Your own facts go against what you’re saying, you retarded fag.

          • kartashok

            Vaishnavas only came to Tamil Nadu in the 900s AD during the reign of Parantaka Chola. We Shaivites were in Tamil Nadu since the BC times.

          • kartashok

            And Sanskrit isn’t the “mother” of all Indo-European languages. It’s just the first Indo-European language to have written religious texts and records. Who do you think they TOOK their written language from? The Indus Valley Elamo-Dravidian natives, my people, of course. All Indians, North and South Indians, have Aryan blood, as long as they are medium or upper caste. CASTE, not region, is the main factor here. This is not Eurocentric, because the Aryans were not from Europe, but the Ural Mountains in Russia, the border between Asia and Europe, the Andronovo-Sintashta culture is where King Bharata and the Suryavanshi came from. They divided themselves into several tribes in Punjab and conquered North India. In Russia they have Rod (Rudra), Matr Sva (Saraswati), Lakshmi (Mokosh/Moksha), Perun (Indra), Zhiva (Parvati), Triglav (Trimurti), Svarog (Brahma), Marzana (literally goddess of death, Kali), Ognyega (Agni), and many more direct parallels to Aryan Rigvedic deities. Which means Hinduism is a direct combination of the Aryan Rigvedic deities WITH the Indus Valley deities like Shiva and proto-Krishna, Nandi, Ganesha, and Muruga which were combined with the Vedic pantheon to create what is now Hinduism.

          • kartashok

            The difference between you and me is that your IQ is too low to interpret the Itihasas correctly.

          • kartashok

            Listen, if every single white demon man, woman and child dropped miraculously dead tomorrow, how would that impact OUR ability to survive and reproduce? Positively of course. Our oppressor would no longer point their nukes and biological and chemical weapons and artificial intelligence towards us, allowing us to not only secure our homeland, but expand and have access to vast new resources. The extermination of the devils in their homelands by shlomo and Chang’s designs could be a Renaissance for the oppressed. The purpose of our people should be to improve ourselves, have children with our own, and have many children that compete in a dog eat dog world that produces the best results for our own offspring, and simultaneously work with anyone and everyone that is trying to wipe out the superpredator race from the face of the earth, the white race. During the entire dinosaur era in the Jurassic and Triassic period, mammals were no larger than a small tree shrew. Once the dinosaurs went extinct, mammals evolved into thousands of beautiful species including humans, who would go on to take over the world and tame it like never before. These are the immutable laws of nature, and a prey who is kind to his predator will be eaten. Our service to God should be to improve our own race, at the expense of our enemies, and preserve and protect our resources for our offspring, with a vicious hatred for the different subspecies of other hominids who oppress us. The trick is to never show the hatred openly, but to show our hatred to our enemies through the furtherance and empowerment of our own people, and acquiring any means to wipe them off the face of the earth when they inevitably attack us.

          • Archaeopteryx

            So you don’t approve of David Frawley? Satguru Sivaya Subramuniyaswami? Sister Nivedita?

          • kartashok

            Never heard of them until now, don’t care for them, they haven’t done anything special. My blood and soil gave me my identity, not them. And even otherwise, the primacy of race ensures that individual actions don’t really matter in the greater group dynamics of nature. The alt right doesn’t care for its token negro bootlickers beyond anything more than a means to achieving an end. I suppose that’s the level of gratitude I could show to these people.

          • Archaeopteryx

            Why do you think so many of our sadhus like Swami Vivekananda, Mahesh Yogi, Srila Prabhupad, Swami Muktananda, and others spent so much time in the west and initiated foreigners into yoga and Vedanta?

          • kartashok

            Because they were:
            1. Ignorant
            2. Willfully liars and greedy for the money such an undertaking would acquire
            3. Sought to capitalize on the hippy movement and other degenerate philosophies that emerged in the late 1950s due to the post-World War 2 malaise. (see point 2)
            4. Believed in silly ideas like world peace and interracial unity which are just biologically, socially and historically incompatible with reality.

          • kartashok

            And in all reality, they served us worse by promoting Hinduism as a universal philosophy, when it was always intimately connected to our blood brothers.

          • phillyaggie

            you don’t even know about them, but you know how they promoted Hinduism? You’re a hoot.

          • kartashok

            I read up about them on Wikipedia after he mentioned them, anyone with an above average IQ can do that. I graduated from UC Berkeley with a 3.9 GPA, with no affirmative action unlike blacks or Hispanics, so I’m not a total idiot.

          • Lulu

            I like you.

          • kartashok

            You are a retard who loves white Indophiles and is too pussy to support REAL Indian nationalism. HATE IS GOLDEN. Hating our enemies and working against them doesn’t make us the same as them, it makes us love our own people.

          • kartashok

            Any ethnicity that does not protect their own tribe and their own blood deserves COMPLETE EXTINCTION! The Bhagavad Gita is talking about Indians, not aliens from outside the subcontinent. The Bhagavad Gita also says the Kali Yuga will be a time of extensive race mixing and the unique bloodlines that made up the tribes of the Vedic era will disintegrate into a bunch of identity-less mud mongrels. And then idiots like you will claim to be authorities on Hinduism, kys.
            And Middle Easterners were all brown until the invasions of the Aryans in Anatolia in 2500 BC, and the later invasions of the Mitanni, the Greeks, Romans, Crusaders and modern European colonialism. Not semi-whites. Whiteness is something that belonged to proto-Indo-Europeans. The R1B haplogroup specifically pertained to Celtic, Germanic, Latin, and certain other Finnic tribes, and has practically nothing to do with the R1A Aryans that invaded India, whose only surviving relatives are the Kalasha people of Pakistan/Afghanistan, the Yaghnobi and other descendants of Scythians and Sogdians in Tajikistan, certain Hepthalite descendants in Xinjiang, China, where the Tocharians came from, and the people of southern Russia and Ukraine. Anglo-Saxon ultra-Nazi racists might as well be a different species, the most intelligent race but also the most cruel.

          • kartashok

            A pig is a pig and a horse is a horse and a monkey is a monkey. A pig born in a horse’s stable doesn’t become a horse. Learn biology and learn about the alarming differences in racial characteristics before preaching nonsense and sucking enemy cock.

          • kartashok

            The Hunas referred to Tocharians, who lived in modern-day Xinjiang you retard. They had NOTHING to do with East Germany, the Tocharians were the people later referred to as Hephthalites, and they invaded India in 150 AD under emperor Kanishka. Does Kanishka sound German to you? They were only distantly related to Slavs through Scythians, but had ZERO to do with Germanic Nazis.

          • kartashok

            Pulinda refers to the tribes of modern-day Balochistan, the Pandavas never made it all the way to Greece you retard. Read history and look up the Cemetery H culture between 1950 BC-1300 BC, that’s the Vedic Aryans. After the Mahabharata era ended in the 1300s BC, they became known as the Kuru Kingdom centered in Kurukshetra. The farthest race they traded with were the Avestan Persians, called the Pallavas. The Greeks were never heard of by Hindus until Alexander the Great invaded India in 326 BC, more than a thousand years after the Mahabharata events took place in North India.

          • phillyaggie

            Ah, so you’re a “Dravidian” and North-South divide chutiya. Seems like it.

          • kartashok

            ALL Indians have Dravidian blood, North Indians just happen to have less of it. Whiteness depends on purity, so if all Indians recognize the common enemy as the white Christian Nazi Amerikkkan, that will unite the Indians. Thanks to the Jews breaking the back of the evil white race after World War 2 we have a country.

          • kartashok

            Threatening to kill children for the color of their skin is part of white culture. YOUR people have literally threatened the lives of innocent babies of Indian-Americans just because you’re mad they took your jobs: http://www.indiawest.com/news/global_indian/watch-yourself-says-note-in-diaper-left-on-doorstep-of/article_0b535970-14c6-11e7-9632-4b3e57984f79.html

          • Ambaa

            And yet you are the one here advocating for murdering people for the color of their skin.

          • kartashok

            No, I advocate that someone else other than our people do the murdering. That way our karma is not affected.

          • Lulu

            You literally just said mixed children should be curb stomped.

            My heart hurts for you. How miserable you must be.

          • kartashok

            Yes, I hope they are curbstomped by your people, as they themselves wish.
            Dailystormer

          • Lulu

            Mere loga? So….your people as well? Lol .

            Okie dokie, phral .

          • kartashok

            I’m talking about white terrorist European-descent people. “Lulu” is a French name, I assumed you were European.

        • Ambaa Choate

          I’m very sorry that you feel that way. Being Hindu is the most important thing in my life and it breaks my heart that anyone could think I was an anti-Hindu. I am struggling to understand why the Hindu religion cannot be practiced by anyone seeking Truth. There are groups of Hindus, such as those in Bali, who are not Indian but are generally still accepted as Hindu. Do the Gods only care about people who are of Indian origin? I know some say I should wait to be born in India but a human embodiment is such a precious gift that I couldn’t stand the thought of wasting it waiting to be born in the right body.

      • kartashok

        Long is a white Christian Catholic child molesting faggot. NOT a Hindu.

    • Agni Ashwin

      Why is Long not a Hindu?

    • Agni Ashwin

      Why is Long not a Hindu?

    • Ambaa Choate

      Well, I can see some of your point. I do wonder, though, as I was brought up with Eastern philosophy. I have been in a Catholic church only about twice in my life and have very little knowledge of it, though that was the religion of half my ancestors (the others being Lutheran). By the time I was born no one I know was still a practicing Catholic at all. I believe that I have a mind that is more Hindu than Christian. How many generations do you think it takes? Will my son, raised completely Hindu, be accepted as such? Is it possible?

    • Zakariya Ali Sher

      I have no idea who Jeffrey Long is, nor why you are so against the idea of conversion, but I would chalk it up as a win for Indian civilization if you can acculturate white converts. Indian culture spread throughout much of Asia due to Hinduism and Buddhism. You realize that the Balinese are descendant from converts, and there were plenty of Hindus in ancient Funan, Srivijaya, Angkor, Majapahit, and the rest of Southeast Asia. Regardless, both Islam and Christianity are quite accepting of converts of all ethnicities, ass are the Indian religions of Buddhism and Sikhism. Or are you going to argue that Indian Buddhism and Sikhism are somehow “incompatable” with Western cultural values?

      Also, I do find it rather ironic that you are quoting Kipling, of all authors…

      • kartashok

        Pink skins, chinks, Muzzloids, blacks, and any other kind of alien who does not have any history within the Indian subcontinent were classified as “Mlecchas” and racial aliens from as long ago as 1300s BC when the events inspiring the Mahabharata occurred. Even the kingdom of Gandhara, in today’s Pashtun lands of northwest Pakistan and Afghanistan, were considered a people distinct from the Vedic people of Punjab and the Indo-Gangetic plains to the east of it.
        Europeans, who are not of the Indo-Iranian branch, have no history nor connection with HInduism, which was created through the blending of Aryan and Elamo-Dravidian (Indus Valley) cultures, thus creating a unique fusion of practices and customs specific to people of the Indian race. So yeah, whites are EVIL colonists and enemies of all brown people, we want nothing to do with them. Hope China nukes those white Mleccha imperialist terrorists.
        Russians and Ukrainians are R1A people intimately connected to Indo-Iranians and they are fighting against Western imperialism, so they are good Aryans.

        • Ambaa

          If I get nuked I’ll probably be reborn Indian… 😉

          • kartashok

            You can only get reborn within your biological sub-species, which in my case would be a desi, and your case would be a Western European.

          • Ser Jorah the Cunt

            you are a retard (i’m a brahmin not a ‘mlechha’) hinduism is a way of life which thrives on acceptance and unity

          • kartashok

            You’re a retarded pig skinned white terrorist. I’m a Brahmin, you’re a Germanic Nazi and a mleccha, a cruel barbarian in whose blood is nothing but evil and arrogance. Brahmins are direct descendants of the Vedic Aryans, no one else. Hinduism is a biological race-religion for the Vedic Aryan and Elamo-Dravidian inhabitants of the Indian subcontinent.
            Stick to worshiping Thor and Odin and being evil like Hitler, that’s your culture. A pig doesn’t turn into a horse if they’re born in a barn, you’ll always be a pig to the vast majority of Hindus. I hope more and more of your kind get brutally raped and murdered in South Africa, the jigs are doing a good job against you demons.

          • Ser Jorah the Cunt

            Teri maa ki choot

          • kartashok

            Yeah and your mom’s cunt is already being groomed by the Muzzies somewhere in Britain hopefully.

          • Ser Jorah the Cunt

            That’s how you speak about women in your Hinduism?

          • kartashok

            Are you retarded? I clearly said it’s the Muslims doing the grooming, not Hindus. And you’d know if you claimed to be a Hindu that women have the status of gods and deities in Hinduism unlike Christ-insanity and Pisslam.

          • Ser Jorah the Cunt

            You sound like a virgin bhakt. I hope you get laid soon buddy.

          • kartashok

            You sound like a faggot cuck that sucks white cock, and gives your wife to Muzzies and pig skins.

          • Ser Jorah the Cunt

            faggot? I’m straighter than the pole your mother dances on bitch

          • kartashok

            Hahaha dancing on poles is what pig skinned females invented and perfected, nice try. You’re either a YT or a self-hating fag cuck, which one is it? Long live Shlomo Shekelstein, death to Nordics.

          • Ser Jorah the Cunt

            your mum didnt perfect it but she was giving it her best. told me she does it as a side job to alleviate the disappointment her bigoted son has become.

          • kartashok

            Soon the Chinese, Jews, Indians, Muslims, etc. will get together and have the technology to wipe out your entire race, much less your country. Race-specific engineered diseases made by Israel, neutron bombs delivered by drones. A few submarine based radar-resistant ICBM nukes of India’s alone could sink your bloody island once and for all, and we will do it too. I just want you to know that 500 years of torturing and terrorizing all of us for the color of our skin (that continues today in American foreign and domestic policy where they preach about human rights and shoot down negroes like dogs without trial) and for the race we were born into, something we have no control over, has a price. That’s why the Jews invented cultural marxism and other tools to destroy you, and the sooner the better.

          • Ser Jorah the Cunt

            you belong in an asylum, you probably are in one, who gave you a phone? call the warden!

          • kartashok

            I’m the virgin? You’re such a faggot you created your account specifically to reply to my comments you waste of space.

          • kartashok

            Hinduism has nothing to do with acceptance or unity, racial segregation and suspicion of outsiders has been prescribed in every legitimate Hindu text from the Rigveda to the Bhagavad Gita. It’s because of liberal cocksuckers in Hinduism that India welcomed all its enemies and got screwed over. Bend over backwards for alien demons and you will no longer have an identity or be free.

          • Ambaa

            What makes you think reincarnation only happens within a “biological sub-species”? Are there not a multitude of stories about people being reborn as different animals, planets, trees, etc.? I don’t think the soul has a cultural bias.

          • kartashok

            Not a cultural bias, regional-biological bias. South and Central Asia only.

        • Vineet Menon

          Mleccha isn’t a racial term. It’s cultural, specifically linguistic. Mleccha were those people who had bad Sanskrit pronunciation or didn’t know Sanskrit.

          • kartashok

            False. Mlecchas = barbarians northwest of Gandhara (Afghanistan). Which includes Persians, Turks and Europeans. Stop with the revisionism.

          • Arturo Esquela

            Perhaps the problem is the use of the term “Hindu” which is both an ethnicity and a religion. If one said, “I practice Sanatana-Dharma,” rather than saying one was Hindu, it would appease the Hindu racists that blog here. The ethnic term predates its use designating a religion.

          • kartashok

            This is how EVIL whites feel about you, cuckold. They want to wipe brown people off the face of the earth. You want to suck the cock of your oppressor and enemy, go ahead. Don’t ask me to come along with you. Whatever helps white genocide and dispossession as fast as possible is the greatest good, and whatever helps them at our expense is the greatest evil from this point on. Survival and reproduction are the two most important needs for ANY race, and whites directly wish to destroy our very existence. Their technological advantage they had over nonwhites historically is being challenged now, and it’s only a matter of time that whites pick on the wrong race. Either way, before they get to India, I want them wiped out in a way that makes their Native American genocide look like a minor tribal war.
            https://littleindia.com/two-indians-injured-following-alleged-racial-attack-in-silicon-valley/
            https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/The_Right_Stuff

      • kartashok

        The white Celtic-Germanic race is genetically predisposed to evil and colonialism unlike any other race on the planet, they are not even the same species as other human beings. There is no reason to give our religion away to DEMONS ON EARTH! Hinduism is for Indians. Why would I want my ENEMIES to practice my religion?
        Indian civilization survives through the genetic presence of the Indian people, specifically the Brahmanas, Kshatriyas, Vaishyas and Shudras who formed the original population of Bharathavarsha in the first place. Enemy aliens have their own cultures and beliefs that they can follow. Hinduism is about ritual purification, not multicultural universalist communism.

        • Ambaa

          If it were universalism, then we would all just be the separate religions we were born because the Truth would exist in all of them. But religions are not universally equal and true so what I am about is not mulitcultural universalisty communism. Hinduism has a unique perspective on Truth and no other path will do.

          It is quite dramatically against the teachings of Hinduism to say that any race is genetically predisposed to something. Especially evil. All human beings of all races are divine. We are all equally part of God. We are certianly not different species.

          Evil has been done by colonizers and I am deeply sorry for that. I will do all that I can to make up for that.

          I fail to see how Hinduism can be Truth if it only applies to some people.

          I’m sorry about the hurt that you are clearly feeling. It is not my desire or intent to take anything from you. But in the end, Hinduism is not yours to give or to withhold. It is a Truth that any human being can learn to find God from.

          • kartashok

            Hinduism is not a religion, it is a racial tradition. Religions are universal by definition, because any random subversive outsider can get in on the religion and claim to be an authority. You are not a Hindu and never will be a Hindu, you are a Western European with your own history, and you need to stop faking your identity. Go try being JEWISH and see how the Jews accept a shiksa like you claiming to be an authority for them. Jews don’t accept converts, they want biological proof of Jewish descent. Which is what Indian Hindus should believe in as far as Hinduism is concerned as well.
            And no, it is your people that are murdering people based on the color of their skin both in the US and in our own homeland. I wish the Jewish elite good luck in doing white genocide.
            http://www.indiawest.com/news/global_indian/your-parents-are-dead-killer-of-silicon-valley-s-naren/article_34681be8-ffc1-11e7-868d-cf1b30347842.html
            https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/In-Goa-Russian-national-held-for-stabbing-3-people/articleshow/52749398.cms

          • Ambaa

            I have consistently emphasized that I am not an expert. I am a student of Hinduism sitting at the feet of a native Master. Judaism does accept converts. You have to go through a process and prove your sincereity, but there are absolutely converts to Judaism.

            There are many racial problems happening in America right now. That is true. I don’t know why you assume that we all act and feel the same way about these atrocities.

          • kartashok

            That’s the other thing. Hinduism doesn’t have “authorities”, nor does it have “masters”. You are either born into it or you aren’t. It’s a tribal, family thing.

          • disqus_kl7kY8xctR

            False

          • kartashok

            It’s true, retard. Read the Vedas.

          • phillyaggie

            Your ideas of “Hinduism” are yours, and very peculiar. Perhaps you’re trolling here, perhaps you really believe in all that you’ve written. But most of it is gibberish. And this is coming from a born “Hindu”.

          • kartashok

            You sound like some faggot cuck that sucks white cock in Philadelphia, you don’t know shit. You probably have the average low caste Indian IQ of 82.

          • Lulu

            Jews literally accept converts. What are you on about?

            Also…why arent Adivasi Hindu?

          • kartashok

            Adivasis are Hindus. The only people who don’t want them to be Hindus are communist liars and other Marxists and Christian missionaries from the West who want to convince them that Brahmins are “oppressing” them so they can convert them to Christianity. They are our people. The West preys on the weakest and poorest of our Hindu brothers to divide and destroy them, eventually to destroy the better off Hindus, until we once again will have no land to call our own. Death to your evil people.

          • Lulu

            Many Adivasi do not consider themselves Hindu.

          • kartashok

            That’s their problem, they need to understand that the white liberal commie and the white Christian Nazi are at their throats trying to kill them off and that the only people they share genetic interests with are right wing upper caste Hindus.

          • Lulu

            Mere loga? Who?

          • kartashok

            Nazimericans, who else?

          • Lulu

            So…you’re a Nazi American? Sounds about right. Mighty white of ya to be so up front about it .

          • kartashok

            No, I said Nazi Amerikkkans are the ones I was talking about. Hope they brutally get murdered, nuked by the Chinese, driven to suicide in vast numbers by overdosing on opioids and fentanyl, etc. Those gun owning white Amerikkkan supremacists want to kill everyone that isn’t a pure white person, WORLDWIDE. They are worse than ISIS. Thank GOD the Jews have caused them so much harm that Manifest Destiny has been reversed, for now.

          • Lulu

            You’re a member of the KKK as well? Not an organization I would join, but whatever creams your Twinkie.

          • kartashok

            You think you’re funny don’t you? Not wasting time with juveniles like you.

          • Lulu

            No. I think I am being purposefully facticious.

          • kartashok

            Jews have ancestry tests in Israel where you have to prove Jewish patronage, like Hitler’s Aryan-ness tests. You will always be a shiksa to those people.

          • Lulu

            Judaism literally accepts converts. Literally.

            Basically what I’m saying is..Judaism literally accepts converts.

      • kartashok

        Those Indonesians and Malaysians, etc. ALL have genetic biological Hindu ancestors who imparted Hinduism to them, and died off/got mixed in with the natives. There was never an instance where Hindus converted a foreign alien race without any biological genetic connection to the Indian people.
        Before the infestation of aggressive light skinned chinks in Southeast Asia starting in the 1100s due to the Mongol invasion of China, most of Southeast Asia had brown skinned people, including many Indians. OUR people built Angkor Wat and ancient Majapahit, not the chinks you see there today who hate us.
        Yellows and whites hate us, and it’s only natural that we should hate them back and not want them claiming ownership over our ancestral way of life. Hinduism is about blood and soil, not “saving souls” like Islam and Christianity. We don’t believe that all humans are equal NOR do we believe that all the world’s people should come together.

      • Anonymouse

        Ibn Muhammad,

        Instead of pushing this “Eastern Philosopher” undesirable towards us, why don’t you naturalize her into the Ummah and teach her the nuances of Shariah?

        Also, Yes, I did quote Kipling. Because Kipling represents the mental archetype of the white race.

  • mjm

    ambaa i was going to invite you to this post with the @ function on disqus. anyway, after looking for you in a couple of comment sections i figured i would just do a link:

    https://disqus.com/home/channel/disqusunderground/discussion/channel-disqusunderground/did_you_know/

  • Archaeopteryx

    Anonymouse has only one follower: kartashok. Both are probably the same person: Aleksey Kartashov, Russian troll.