Eastern Orthodoxy & Catholicism (Index Page)

 Cover (555 x 838, 175K)

[see full book and purchase information]

***

Asterisked posts are links to old Blogspot papers of mine. Allow a minute or two for them to upload and select archived versions (if necessary) from July 2015 or earlier.

***

GENERAL

Sack of Constantinople (1204) & Unknown Byzantine Atrocities [1998]

Response to an Orthodox Critic Concerning My Supposed Ignorance of Orthodoxy & Illegitimate Apologetic Methodology (vs. Perry Robinson) [7-7-04] *

Critique of Orthodoxy (John McAlpine) [7-21-04] *

Discussion on Orthodox Caesaropapism & Proper Historiography (vs. “Theophan” & Joel Kalvesmaki) [8-19-04] *

Overview of Theological and Ecclesiological Catholic-Orthodox Disagreements / The Unique Case of the Oriental Orthodox [11-28-07] *

Orthodoxy & Catholicism Read by Czech Bishops & Priests [6-16-11]

Exchange with an Anti-Catholic Orthodox: Originally on the Papacy (vs. Richard A. Shaward) [Facebook, 12-2-11]

Further Thoughts on Catholic-Orthodox Discussion [Facebook, 12-20-13] [+ earlier, humorous installment: about someone trashing me because I made a “patristic typo”: Facebook, 12-19-13]

Preface to 3rd Revised 2015 Edition of Orthodoxy and Catholicism: A Comparison [6-11-14]

Crusades Controversy & “Discussion” (?) w Orthodox [8-14-14]

Orthodoxy & Catholicism: A Comparison: Reply to Introduction (Fr. Deacon Daniel Dozier) [8-18-14]

 

FILIOQUE / HOLY TRINITY

Filioque: Catholic-Orthodox Dialogue (William Klimon) [July 1997]

The Holy Spirit, Procession, and the Love Between the Father and the Son (Church Teaching) [7-3-09] *

“Western” View of the Holy Trinity, Monarchia, Procession, Etc. (vs. David Waltz and Drake Shelton) [3-5-12]

 

THE PAPACY

Pope St. Leo the Great, the “Robber” Council of 449, and the Council of Chalcedon in 451 (Blessed John Henry Cardinal Newman) [1993; re-posted to Facebook on 1-27-17]

50 New Testament Proofs for Petrine Primacy & the Papacy [1994]

Pope Silvester and the Council of Nicaea (vs. James White) [August 1997]

The Development of the Papacy (John Henry Cardinal Newman) [1997] *

Bible on Papal & Church Infallibility [2007]

Council of Nicea: Reply to James White: Its Relationship to Pope Sylvester, Athanasius’ Views, & the Unique Preeminence of Catholic Authority [4-2-07]

The Orthodox Formally Recognize Papal Primacy in High Level Ecumenical Talks [12-17-07] *

Papal Participation in the First Seven Ecumenical Councils [4-22-09]

The Nature of Papal Leadership: “Servant of Servants” [from Karl Adam; Facebook, 2-2-12]

Quick, Highly Effective Argument for the Existence of the Papacy in the First 200 Years [Facebook, 3-13-13]

The Papacy & Conciliarity (or, Collegiality): How Popes Routinely Consult Bishops, Priests, and Laity Prior to Momentous Decrees [9-13-14]

Did Pope Gregory the Great Deny Papal Primacy & Supremacy? [9-16-17]

Pope St. Leo the Great (r. 440-461) and Papal Supremacy [9-19-17]

Shock! Former Catholic Rod Dreher Loves Lawler’s Pope-Bashing Book (Sin in the Church and Dreher’s Inadequately Explained Rejection of Catholic Doctrine) [2-22-18]

 

DIVORCE AND ANNULMENT

Divorce: Early Church Teaching [Oct. 1998]

Dialogue on Annulment & Divorce: Essentially Different? [1997-1999]

Biblical Evidence for Annulments [2002]

Biblical Evidence for Prohibiting Divorce [2004]

Annulment is Not “Catholic Divorce” [11-17-15]

 

CONTRACEPTION

Contraception: Early Church Teaching (William Klimon) [1998]

Dialogue: Contraception vs. NFP: Crucial Ethical Distinctions [2-16-01]

Biblical Evidence Against Contraception [5-3-06]

Dialogue on Contraception & Natural Family Planning (NFP) (vs. Grubb) [5-16-06] *

Does Orthodoxy Allow Contraception Or Not? [1-29-05; rev. 6-22-06] *

The Bible on the Blessing of [Many] Children [3-9-09]

 

ORIGINAL SIN

Group Discussion on Eastern vs. Western Conceptions of Original Sin (with Eastern Catholics and Orthodox) (+ discussion on a second continuing Facebook thread) [Facebook, 6-28-14 and 6-30-14; note: later portions of the long initial thread become a more general Catholic-Orthodox discussion, mostly between myself and John Fiscus] 

 

PRIESTLY CELIBACY

A New (?) Argument in Favor of Mandatory Celibacy of Catholic Priests in the Western / Latin Rite [11-16-12] [see also vigorous Facebook discussion with Orthodox participants: 7-31-14]

 

HOLY EUCHARIST

Eucharist: Orthodox and Catholic Views [5-3-13 and 15 and 20 September 2016] 

 

ECUMENISM / ECCLESIOLOGY

A Response to Orthodox Critiques of Catholic Apostolicity [1997] *

Indefectibility and the Claim of Various Anti-Ecumenical Orthodox to Exclusive Apostolic Succession [2004] *

Orthodox-Catholic Reunion: Some Preliminary Thoughts [7-5-05] *

The Orthodox Formally Recognize Papal Primacy in High Level Ecumenical Talks [12-17-07] *

Orthodox & Catholic Ecclesiology: Possible Synthesis? [11-23-11]

 

THEOSIS

Theosis and the Exalted Virgin Mary [7-11-04]

St. Bonaventure on Deification / Theosis [Facebook, 3-11-14]

St. Teresa of Avila on Deification / Theosis [Facebook, 4-11-14]

 

PURGATORY

Is Purgatory a “Place” or a “Condition”?: Misconceptions From [Eastern Orthodox] Fr. Ambrose About My Opinion (and the Church’s View) / Also: Development and Alleged Historical Revisionism [7-24-05]

EXTERNAL LINKS
*****
Updated on 25 April 2018.
*** 
"Quite.Do the self-identifying ‘pro-life’ crowd mind being referred to as the ‘forced-birther’ contingent? I have ..."

“Pro-Abortion”: Reply to an Objection to ..."
"Silly Protestants. How can they agree on which books on unicorn dances are authoritative, divinely-inspired ..."

Development of the Biblical Canon: Protestant ..."
"Hi Vic. I’ve been following with interest your discussions with Dave Armstrong. I note one ..."

Dialogue w Agnostic/Deist on the “Problem ..."
"I find it odd how Dave Armstrong, in calling his opposition "pro-abort," doesn't expect to ..."

“Pro-Abortion”: Reply to an Objection to ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • If you can, please read the following website and prepare a reply.

    http://www.johnsanidopoulos.com/2010/12/delusions-of-catholic-mystics.html

    Thank you.

  • I have a policy of not wasting my time debating anti-Catholics. This stuff is garbage: not worth anyone's time, in my opinion.

  • I am disappointed and do not understand. You "have a policy of not wasting my time debating anti-Catholics", but you have a whole section of your website doing so:

    http://www.patheos.com/blogs/davearmstrong/2006/11/anti-catholicism-index-page.html

    This even includes "Orthodox Anti-Catholicism" as well as such already discredited anti-Catholics as Jack Chick.

    Yet, you will not respond to Alexei Osipov, a well known Russian Orthodox theologian, professor and lecturer from the Orthodox Theological Seminary in Moscow? Check the internet. He is a widely popular pedagogue, publicist and defender of Russian Orthodoxy and apologist of Eastern Christianity. Most of his publications never mention Catholicism.

    I know that your time is valuable and that you must pick and choose whose writings you will answer. But, you've heard the old saying that an unanswered lie becomes the truth in 24 hrs. There are now other Orthodox websites attacking Catholic Marian apparitions (not necessary to our Faith) as unholy delusions.

    http://www.orthodoxinfo.com/inquirers/marian_apparitions.aspx

    With no Catholic replies, readers of these sites will think we have no response that can be made. But, that is your decision.

  • At least one Catholic apologist had the religious courage to attempt a response to this Orthodox slur. But, it still awaits a full rebuttal. Would that it were yours.

    http://us.mc839.mail.yahoo.com/mc/welcome?.partner=sbc&.gx=1&.tm=1291934240&.rand=df03f7k0ea5qg#_pg=showMessage&sMid;=0&&filterBy;=&.rand=2041942057&midIndex;=0∣=1_444188_AG9ck0UAADwXTQFUjQY4yAmBZ3U&f;=1&fromId;=athr@LOC.GOV&m;=1_444188_AG9ck0UAADwXTQFUjQY4yAmBZ3U,1_435290_AG1ck0UAAAgWTQEZFAsCfAWE2TQ,1_433182_AGlck0UAASIlTQEIOA4xghnEqaI,1_428585_AGFck0UAAAcwTQD%2FRAatgxbSND4,1_424265_AGVck0UAAH9zTQDTTw8WIh3lf7I,1_422012_AGVck0UAAN2rTQC%2FSACED2VfMnk,&sort;=dateℴ=down&startMid;=0&hash;=bddbc285a4b0236cb2e6efcd30a6b0bd&.jsrand=6500554

  • Some things are beneath reply. This is not a matter of courage (I have 650 debates posted) but of stewardship of time under God.