Lutheranism: Catholic Critique (Index Page)

Melanchthon7Philip Melanchthon (1497-1560): leader of Lutheranism after Luther’s death; 1532 portrait by Lucas Cranach the Elder (1472-1553) [public domain / Wikimedia Commons]

*****

Asterisked posts are Internet Archive versions of my old Blogspot papers. Be sure to allow a minute or two for them to load, and make selections from July 2015 or earlier.

***

Am I “Anti-Luther” or “Anti-Lutheran”? [5-28-09 / 1-6-15; posted to Facebook on 8-26-17]

*****

LUTHERANISM AND THE FATHERS 

*

Honor Thy Denominations Rather Than Thy Church Fathers? (Lutherans, Sola Scriptura, and the Fathers) (vs. “CPA” & Steve Parks) [5-29-05] *

Dialogue with a Lutheran on Whether Lutheranism or Catholicism is More Consistent With Patristic and Early Church Beliefs (+ Part II) (+ Part III) (vs. Kristo Miettinen) [June 17-23, 2005] *

*

*
Luther’s Views of Augustine & the Church Fathers
[July 2009]

Dialogue with a Lutheran: Church Fathers & Sola Scriptura (vs. Nathan Rinne) [10-13-11]

Dialogue with a Lutheran: Rule of Faith / Fathers / Ecclesiology (vs. Nathan Rinne) [10-17-11]


SOTERIOLOGY (THEOLOGY OF SALVATION, JUSTIFICATION, & SANCTIFICATION)

*

Baptismal Regeneration: Central Doctrine, According to Luther & Lutheranism [1996]

Lutheranism vs. Catholicism (Particularly Regarding Original Sin and Faith Alone, and Including Extensive Catholic Commentary on the Book of Concord)  [1-20-01] *

Confessional Lutheran, Arminian, and Melanchthonian Soteriology Compared (Are Philip Melanchthon and Arminians Semi-Pelagians?) [6-16-03] *

Dialogue on Luther’s “Getting to a Gracious God” (vs. “CPA”) [6-4-06] *

Dialogue with Four Lutherans on Common Ground Regarding Justification and Salvation [2-1-07] *

Church Fathers & Justification: Martin Chemnitz vs. Catholicism [9-9-07]

Dialogue with a Lutheran: Salvation & Miscellany (vs. Nathan Rinne) [10-14-11]

Catholic-Lutheran Dialogue on Justification and “Faith Alone” (“Adomnan” vs. Nathan Rinne; in the comments section) [10-15-11] *

 “Leaven” of the Pharisees: Hypocrisy or False Doctrine? (vs. Nathan Rinne) [11-3-11]

Is God Alone Holy, According to Scripture? Or Can We Be Too?  (vs. Ken Howes) [5-3-17]

Debate with a Lutheran Pastor on Faith and Works [5-4-17]

Martin Luther and Lutherans on Mortal & Venial Sins [10-30-17]

 

LUTHERANISM AND MARY

*
*
*
*
*
*
*


THE DEATH PENALTY FOR HERETICS / THEFT OF CATHOLIC CHURCH PROPERTY
 

*
*
*
*
*
*
 
ECCLESIOLOGY / THE “REFORMATION” / RULE OF FAITH / SECTARIANISM
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*

Priests, Levites, and Josiah’s Destruction of the High Places: Closer to Sola Scriptura or Catholicism? (vs. “CPA”) (+ Part Two / Part Three / Part Four / Part Five) [4-9-06] *

My Respect For Lutherans [3-20-07; reposted to Facebook on 10-23-17]

Reply to Two Lutheran Pastors on Fundamental Misconceptions Regarding the Catholic Position on the Death Penalty [3-22-07] *

Critique of Martin Chemnitz’ Examination of Trent: Scripture I (Poisoning the Well as to the Catholic Rule of Faith and Veneration of Holy Scripture) [8-25-07] *

*

Melanchthon in 1530 Longed for Return of Catholic Bishops [11-30-07]

Zwingli, Bucer, Oecolampadius: Luther & Lutherans Not Christians [1-10-08]

Erasmus vs. Luther Disputes Documented [Feb. 2009]

Dialogue with a Lutheran Inquirer [WELS], on Lutheran-Catholic Differences [4-6-09]

John Calvin Rebukes Lutheran “Beasts” and “Evil”, Calls Luther an Idolater [3-23-10; posted to Facebook on 8-26-17]

Melanchthon’s Agonized Tears Over Early Protestant Divisions [6-15-11; additions on 10-11-17]

Bible on Submission to Church & Apostolic Tradition + Biblical Condemnation of the Rebellious & Schismatic Aspects of the Protestant Revolt [8-27-11]

Dialogue with a Lutheran: Church Fathers & Sola Scriptura (vs. Nathan Rinne) [10-13-11]

Dialogue with a Lutheran: Rule of Faith / Fathers / Ecclesiology (vs. Nathan Rinne) [10-17-11]

Early Protestant “Unity”: Calvin vs. Westphal vs. Luther / Calvin Denies Baptismal Regeneration [11-6-11]

Luther: Monks & Priests More “Earnest” Than Lutherans [11-10-11]

Dialogue with a Lutheran on Ecclesiology & OT Indefectibility Analogies (vs. Nathan Rinne) [11-22-11]

Dialogue on the Term, “Protestant Reformation” and Alternatives (“Era of Reformations” and “Protestant Revolt”) (vs. Dr. Edwin W. Tait) [1-7-14]

Dialogue with a Lutheran on Christian Authority [5-6-16]

Critique of Ten Exaggerated Claims of the “Reformation” [10-31-17; its 500th anniversary date]



THE EUCHARIST, SACRIFICE OF THE MASS, AND THE SACRAMENTS
 

Baptismal Regeneration: Central Doctrine, According to Luther & Lutheranism [1996]

Sacramentarian Controversies (Calvin vs. Luther vs. Zwingli) [3-29-04]

Philip Melanchthon: Death for Denying the Real Presence (He Later Denied the Real Presence Himself) [5-23-06]

Lutherans, Corpus Christi, & Eucharistic Adoration [6-18-07]

Quiz on Early Protestant / “Reformation” Eucharistic Harmony [8-23-09]

John Calvin Rebukes Lutheran “Beasts” and “Evil”, Calls Luther an Idolater [3-23-10; posted to Facebook on 8-26-17]

Quibble About Lutheran Dislike of the Term “Consubstantiation” [4-20-11]

Early Protestant “Unity”: Calvin vs. Westphal vs. Luther / Calvin Denies Baptismal Regeneration [11-6-11]

Mass: Re-Sacrifice? (vs. Lutheran Pastor Ken Howes) [4-2-12]

SAINTS: INVOCATION AND INTERCESSION OF

*
Reply to Lutheran on Invocation of Saints (vs. Jordan Cooper) [12-1-15]
*


LUTHERAN-CATHOLIC DIALOGUE

(WITH PASTORS LARRY NICHOLS AND BEN MATON [LCMS] )

*
*
*


LUTHERAN-CATHOLIC DIALOGUE

(WITH APOLOGIST NATHAN RINNE)
*

Dialogue with a Lutheran: Introductory Matters [10-12-11]

Dialogue with a Lutheran: Church Fathers & Sola Scriptura [10-13-11]

Dialogue with a Lutheran: Salvation & Miscellany [10-14-11]

Catholic-Lutheran Dialogue on Justification and “Faith Alone” (“Adomnan” vs. Nathan Rinne; in the comments section) [10-15-11] *

Dialogue with a Lutheran: Rule of Faith / Fathers / Ecclesiology [10-17-11]

 “Leaven” of the Pharisees: Hypocrisy or False Doctrine? [11-3-11]

Dialogue with a Lutheran on Ecclesiology & OT Indefectibility Analogies [11-22-11]

 

LUTHERAN-CATHOLIC DIALOGUE

(WITH PROFESSOR OF HISTORY “CPA”)

Reply Concerning Bogus Notions of the Catholic View of the Bible [2-21-05] *

Reply on Catholic Apologists and the Biblical Canon [2-21-05] *

Response on Christian Unity and Ecclesiology [6-3-05] *

Dialogue on 16th-Century Religious Tolerance [2-15-06] *

16th Century Theft of Church Properties (vs. Lutheran Historian) [2-22-06]

Priests, Levites, and Josiah’s Destruction of the High Places: Closer to Sola Scriptura or Catholicism? (+ Part Two / Part Three / Part Four / Part Five) [4-9-06] *

Dialogue on Luther’s “Getting to a Gracious God” [6-4-06] *

Dialogues with Lutheran Professor “CPA” (Series) [compiled on 5-10-16]

 

LUTHERAN-CATHOLIC DIALOGUE

(WITH VARIOUS)

Why I am a Catholic / Why I am a Lutheran / The Protestant Myth of Origins (vs. Eric Phillips) [3-30-05] *

“The Prayer of a Righteous Man Availeth Much” (Jas 5:16: KJV) (Dialogue with a Lutheran) [6-8-05]

Dialogue with a Lutheran Inquirer, on Lutheran-Catholic Differences [4-6-09] *

Reply to Lutheran on Invocation of Saints (vs. Jordan Cooper) [12-1-15]

My Dialogues with Lutherans (Series) [compiled 4-11-16]

*
EARLY LUTHERAN “ECUMENISM” AND TOLERANCE (?)
 
The Protestant Revolt: Its Tragic Initial Impact [6-11-91; rev. 10-31-03; 3-8-07] *
*
Protestant Inquisitions: “Reformation” Intolerance & Persecution [June 1991; rev. 10-31-03, 3-7-07. Greatly abridged and re-typeset on 9-14-17]
*
*
*
*
*
The Early Protestants Were Ecumenical? Not! (vs. Dr. Paul Owen) (+ Part Two) [11-9-04 + 9-7-05] *

*

“Absurd” Protestant Divisions: Calvin’s Revealing Lament to Melanchthon [2-6-06]

Word “Protestant” Stemmed from Intolerance of Catholic Worship [2-8-06]

Dialogue on 16th-Century Religious Tolerance (vs. “CPA”) [2-15-06] *

Melanchthon in 1530 Longed for Return of Catholic Bishops [11-30-07]

Zwingli, Bucer, Oecolampadius: Luther & Lutherans Not Christians [1-10-08]

John Calvin Rebukes Lutheran “Beasts” and “Evil”, Calls Luther an Idolater [3-23-10; posted to Facebook on 8-26-17]

 

PHILIP MELANCHTHON 

*
*
*
*
*
*
Luther & Melanchthon: Bigamy of Philip of Hesse is Biblical (Hartmann Grisar) [2-14-07; abridged on 11-2-17]
*
*
*

*

John Calvin Did Not Pray to Philip Melanchthon [9-19-09; revised, with retraction, on 5-3-16]

Melanchthon’s Agonized Tears Over Early Protestant Divisions [6-15-11; additions on 10-11-17]


CRITIQUE OF MARTIN CHEMNITZ’ EXAMEN
 


PRAYER FOR THE DEAD / PURGATORY / HADES

*
*
 
Last Updated: 2 November 2017.


*****

"I can't follow your logic.Definition of enmity : positive, active, and typically mutual hatred or ..."

Sinless Mary: Dialogue w Old Testament ..."
"I would like to jump into the middle of this discussion and start at the ..."

Sinless Mary: Dialogue w Old Testament ..."
"Did Mary sin? Yes. If she had not, scripture would have been wrong when it ..."

Sinless Mary: Dialogue w Old Testament ..."
"We are not celebrating Jesus birth. He was born in late September early October. The ..."

Christmas Trees: Where & When Did ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment